Chapter 3: Margaret’s Warning

Daniel caught Elizabeth’s wrist before she reached the envelope.
“Let go of me,” she said.
“Not until you tell us why Grandma knew you in 1994.”
Elizabeth pulled free and pointed at me.
“This is your mother’s doing.
She always wanted to turn you against me.”
“My mother has been gone for years.”
“And she’s still controlling this family.”
Lily pressed against my side.
I placed the letter inside my cardigan and led her toward the door.
“Go downstairs, sweetheart.”
“But the costumes—”
“I’ll bring them.”
Elizabeth blocked the doorway.
“No.
Lily stays where I can see her.”
Daniel moved between them.
“Lily, wait for us downstairs.”
She looked at her mother, then hurried away.
When her footsteps faded, Daniel shut the door.
“Open it,” he said to me.
Elizabeth’s voice dropped.
“If you love your son, you won’t.”
I broke the seal.
Inside were three pages and a small piece of green fabric.
My mother’s writing shook across the first line.
“My dear daughter, the girl in the photograph is Elizabeth Mercer.
When she was eight, she came to my sewing room because she was afraid to go home.”
Daniel turned toward his wife.
“You said you grew up in another state.”
“My childhood is none of your mother’s business.”
“I’m your husband.”
“That doesn’t entitle her to tear open every scar I have.”
I continued reading.
“Elizabeth stayed with me after school for nearly a year.
I made her the green costume because she had never owned one.
When the authorities moved her to her aunt Vivian’s home, she made me promise that if she ever had a daughter, we would make the same costume together.”
Daniel’s anger softened.
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
Elizabeth’s eyes filled, but her mouth tightened.
“Because I was poor.
Because my father frightened everyone.
Because your grandmother saw me wearing secondhand shoes and eating food from her cupboard.
Is that what you wanted to hear?”
“No,” Daniel said.
“I wanted the truth.”
“There’s more,” I whispered.
Elizabeth reached for the pages again.
“Don’t read it.”
I stepped back.
“Years later, Elizabeth returned.
She asked me to keep our history from Daniel.
I agreed, but then she asked me to sign papers concerning the trust I created for Daniel’s first daughter.
I refused.”
Daniel stared at her.
“What trust?”
“I don’t know anything about a trust,” Elizabeth said.
The next line answered him.
“The trust contains the proceeds from my sewing business and is meant for the child’s education.
Elizabeth already knew she wished to name her daughter Lily.
If this letter is being read, Lily has reached the age when the first accounting must be delivered.”
Daniel held out his hand.
“Where is that accounting?”
“I never received one.”
Elizabeth backed toward the trunk.
“Your grandmother was confused.
She invented things.”
“My mother knew your name, your childhood, and Lily’s name.”
“She was obsessed with rescuing people.”
I unfolded the green fabric.
Something hard was sewn inside its hem.
“Grandma wrote one more sentence.”
Daniel came closer.
“What does it say?”
I read it aloud.
“Elizabeth once copied the key.
I moved the evidence before she could take it.
The real key is hidden in the wing she left behind.”
All three of us looked at the faded costume.
May you like
Its remaining wing had been cut open.
Elizabeth was holding a tiny brass key.