Spotlight

Chapter 7: Everything She Didn't Expect Me to Have

Cynthia Marsh filed the formal complaint with the county recorder's office on a Thursday morning.

By Friday afternoon, she had called to tell me that the examiner had flagged the document immediately.

"The notary stamp is real," she said, "but the notary who supposedly witnessed the signature retired two years before the document's stated date.

She passed away eight months after that.

Someone used her stamp and her license number on a document she could not have witnessed."

"So it's not just a forged signature," I said.

"It's a forged signature on a document with a fraudulent notary stamp.

That's a different category of problem for whoever filed it." Cynthia paused.

"I've referred the matter to the district attorney's office.

They'll reach out to you separately.

In the meantime, the document has been flagged in the county record and cannot be used as supporting evidence in any civil filing."

I thanked her and put the phone down.

The second call came from a detective named Paulson, that same afternoon.

We spoke for forty minutes.

I answered every question and told him about Gerald Fitch, about the months of Robert's illness, about the two visits to our home, and about how Fitch had come back into the picture through Sarah.

"Do you know the name of the mutual contact?" Paulson asked.

"I don't.

But my son may."

"We'll be in touch with him directly."

After I hung up, I sat for a while.

The house was quiet.

The afternoon light was coming through the living room window at the angle it always did in November, low and golden, laying across the carpet in the same pattern it had for twenty years.

Then my phone rang again.

A number I recognized this time.

Sarah.

I answered.

"Kimberly." Her voice was controlled.

Careful in a way it hadn't been when she was standing in my kitchen giving me an eleven o'clock deadline.

"I think we should talk."

"All right," I said.

"Not on the phone.

Can I come over?"

I looked at the clock.

It was nearly four.

"Tomorrow morning," I said.

"Ten o'clock."

She arrived at five past ten, alone.

She sat in the chair across from mine and folded her hands in her lap.

She was wearing less makeup than usual.

The certainty that had been in her posture three days ago was gone, replaced with something quieter and more careful.

"I didn't know the document was fake," she said.

"Tell me how you came to have it."

She exhaled.

"Gerald Fitch contacted me in September through a colleague.

He said he had been a financial advisor to your husband and that there were arrangements Robert had made that hadn't been properly executed in the will.

He said David had a rightful claim that was being overlooked."

"And you believed him."

"I did my own research.

The law firm I consulted said the document appeared to be valid.

I had no reason to think—"

"You had one reason," I said.

"You wanted it to be real."

She looked at the window.

"If you had come to me," I said, "and told me that someone had approached you with a claim about Robert's estate, I would have sat down with you.

I would have gone through every document I have from those months.

I would have shown you everything." I waited until she looked back at me.

"Instead, you sent a lawyer.

You stood in my kitchen and gave me a deadline.

You used a forged document to try to take something that was never yours to take."

Sarah's hands tightened in her lap.

"I know."

"Do you know what that document actually is?" I asked.

"Do you know what Fitch did?"

From the way her face shifted, I could see that David had told her.

Or the detective had called.

"He used a dead woman's notary stamp," I said.

"He forged my husband's signature while my husband was dying.

He filed it with the county and waited to see if anyone would ever use it.

And you did."

Her chin dropped.

"I'm not going to pursue anything against you personally," I said.

"Not unless my attorney advises me otherwise.

But I need you to provide every communication you have with Gerald Fitch to the detective who contacts you.

Every text, every email, every voicemail.

If you cooperate fully and immediately, that matters.

If you don't—"

"I will," she said.

The certainty in her voice this time was different.

Smaller.

I stood up.

"I think we're finished for now."

Sarah stood too.

She moved toward the door, then stopped.

"Kimberly." She turned back.

"I'm sorry.

For what happened in this kitchen.

For the deadline.

For all of it.

I was wrong."

I held the door open.

"I know," I said.

She left.

I watched the street until her car disappeared around the corner.

Then I went back inside, sat down, and called David.

"She was here," I told him.

"I know.

She called me from the car." A pause.

"She's going to cooperate."

"Good."

Another pause.

Longer this time.

"Mom," he said.

May you like

"What happens to Fitch?"

"That," I said, "is no longer my problem to solve."

Related Stories

Other posts