Spotlight

Chapter 6: The Man Who Helped With the Paperwork

Gerald Fitch wasn't difficult to find.

He had a website.

Financial consulting services, it said, with a photo of a man in his early sixties smiling in front of a bookshelf.

Gray suit.

Confident posture.

The kind of headshot designed to make older clients feel reassured.

I remembered him differently.

Thinner then, with reading glasses he was always taking off and putting back on.

He had sat at my kitchen table and explained the refinancing documents to Robert in a patient, unhurried voice.

He had accepted the cup of coffee I offered him.

He had asked after Robert's prognosis with what had seemed like genuine concern.

I had trusted him because Robert did.

I called a property attorney that afternoon.

Her name was Cynthia Marsh.

She had been recommended to me by a neighbor who had gone through a boundary dispute two years earlier.

She was brisk, she was clear, and when I explained what Hargrove had shown me, she asked me to email her the copy before the end of the day.

"Don't contact Fitch," she said.

"Don't contact Sarah directly about the document.

And don't let this go longer than a week without filing a formal complaint with the county recorder's office."

"What happens after that?"

"Forgery of a notarized document is a felony in this state," she said.

"If that signature is fraudulent and can be demonstrated to be fraudulent — and comparing it to the signatures on your legitimate documents will likely be sufficient — then whoever filed it is looking at crjminal exposure, not just civil."

I wrote that down.

"What about the person who brought the document to my daughter-in-law?" I asked.

"If she used it in good faith—"

"If she used it to make a legal claim against your property, good faith becomes harder to argue," Cynthia said.

"We'd need to know the exact nature of what she presented to her lawyer.

That's a conversation worth having with your son."

That evening, David came to the house alone.

He sat at the kitchen table in the same chair he'd sat in as a boy when he had something difficult to say.

I made coffee.

He wrapped both hands around the mug.

"She told me Fitch had proof that Dad had a private arrangement," David said.

"That he'd promised someone a portion of the equity if they helped him during the illness.

She said it was being hidden from me."

"Hidden by whom?"

He looked at the table.

"By you."

I sat down across from him and said nothing.

"I didn't believe it," he said quickly.

"Not really.

But she kept pushing.

She said we were entitled to investigate.

That it was only fair.

And I—" He stopped.

"I let her.

I told myself I was just keeping the peace."

"You let her send a lawyer to your mother's house," I said.

"Three days after I opened my door to you."

The words weren't loud.

They didn't need to be.

David set the mug down.

His eyes were red at the edges.

"I know."

"Your father and I were married for thirty-one years.

He was ill for fourteen months.

In those fourteen months, I sat with him every day.

I drove him to every appointment.

I signed every document he couldn't sign himself, and I did it in front of notaries and witnesses and his actual physician." I kept my voice level.

"There was no private arrangement.

There was no hidden equity.

There was a man named Gerald Fitch who came to our home, earned your father's trust, and apparently used it."

David's jaw was tight.

"What did he get out of it?"

"I don't know yet.

Possibly nothing yet.

Possibly he was building toward a claim and never got the chance to use it while your father was alive.

Possibly someone found the document recently and approached him — or he approached them." I looked at David directly.

"Did Sarah contact him, or did he contact her?"

David thought for a moment.

"She said he reached out to her.

Through a mutual connection.

Someone she knows from her work."

"What does Sarah do?"

"Real estate consulting." He said it quietly, like he was hearing the answer to a question he hadn't known to ask.

I let that land.

"Mom." His voice dropped.

"She didn't know the document was forged.

I have to believe she didn't know."

"Maybe not," I said.

"But she hired a lawyer and sent a letter to my home before she verified anything.

She threatened me with it in my own kitchen." I stood and took my mug to the sink.

"Whether she knew or not, she used it."

David was quiet for a long time.

"What do you need from me?" he asked.

"I need every communication you have between Sarah and Gerald Fitch.

Texts.

Emails.

Anything she may have forwarded to you." I turned from the sink.

"And I need you to decide whose side you're on.

Not because I'm asking you to choose between your wife and your mother.

But because what happens next is going to require you to be honest about what you know.

And I need to know if you're able to do that."

He looked up at me.

"I'm on the right side," he said.

"Whatever that costs."

I nodded.

He pulled out his phone and started going through his messages.

May you like

I refilled his coffee without being asked.

We sat at that kitchen table until almost midnight.

Related Stories

Other posts