Chapter 7: When Thomas Decided to Fight
The attorney I called the next morning was named Patricia Howe.
My sister Janet had used her two years earlier for a property dispute and described her simply as the kind of woman who doesn't lose.
Patricia reviewed Rebecca's documents within forty-eight hours and called me on a Wednesday evening.
"This is solid," she said.
"I want to file a motion to reopen the settlement by end of month.
We'll be arguing fraudulent concealment.
With what Rebecca has, and with the state attorney showing preliminary interest in the criminal side, Thomas is going to be under pressure from two directions at once." She paused.
"He's going to come at you, Claire.
I want you prepared for that."
"What do you mean?"
"I mean his attorney will look for anything they can use.
They'll examine your finances, your relationships, your parenting, your decisions during the marriage.
They will try to make this about you."
My stomach tightened.
"I know."
"Good.
It won't work.
But it will be unpleasant." Another pause.
"There's already been contact from Thomas's side.
His attorney sent a letter this morning.
They're claiming the bank account was part of a business trust and legally protected from disclosure."
"Rebecca said the trust argument won't hold."
"It won't.
The account wasn't structured correctly as a trust and there's no independent trustee named.
It's a creative argument, not a legal one." A brief silence.
"They also made a suggestion that the documentation was obtained improperly by a private investigator with no standing in the case."
"Is that an issue?"
"No.
Martin Hale provided those documents voluntarily and Rebecca's investigation was legally conducted.
But it tells me Thomas is already trying to shift the story from what he hid to how we found it." Patricia's voice stayed even.
"Let him try.
The numbers don't move."
Three days later, Thomas called me directly.
I had not spoken to him since the birthday party.
I almost let it go to voicemail.
Then I thought about what Patricia had said — be prepared — and I answered.
"Claire." His voice was different.
The executive smoothness was under strain now.
"Thomas."
"I want to talk about Ethan."
"Then talk to your custody attorney."
"This isn't about custody.
It's about the fact that our son is barely speaking to me.
He won't return my calls.
I'm his father and you've poisoned him against me."
My grip on the phone tightened.
"Ethan was standing at the edge of his own birthday pool when he heard you tell a financial investigator that you hid money from his mother.
I didn't poison him.
You educated him."
"He's fifteen.
He doesn't understand what he heard."
"He understood enough."
Thomas's voice dropped.
"I'm asking you, as the mother of my children, to let this go.
File nothing.
Walk away.
I will make a fair offer through my attorney.
Something genuinely fair.
Not fifty thousand.
More."
"You should know," I said carefully, "that I am recording this call."
A silence.
"Claire—"
"Patricia Howe is my attorney.
All communication should go through her office." I paused.
"And Thomas?
Don't call me directly again."
I hung up.
My hand was trembling slightly.
I set the phone face-down on the counter and pressed both palms flat against the surface until it steadied.
Then I picked the phone back up and called Patricia.
"He called me directly," I said when she answered.
"I recorded it.
He implied he would make a larger offer if I dropped everything."
"Good," Patricia said.
"Send me the recording.
That's attempted settlement interference and I'd like his attorney to know we have it."
"There's something else." I hesitated.
"He said I'd poisoned Ethan against him."
"What did you say?"
"I told him Ethan understood what he heard."
Patricia was quiet for a moment.
Then: "That was the right answer." A brief pause.
"Claire, I need you to hold steady.
He's going to try several more things before this is done.
This was the first one."
"What's the next one?"
"I don't know yet," she said.
"But we'll handle it when it comes."
She was right.
Two days later, it came.
A message arrived through a mutual acquaintance — a woman named Diane who had been in our social circle for years.
Diane called me in the morning, voice careful and strange.
"Claire, I don't know how to say this.
Thomas reached out to me.
He wants me to write a statement — about some things he says happened during your marriage.
About your state of mind.
Your stability." She stopped.
"I want you to know I told him absolutely not."
I closed my eyes.
"Thank you, Diane."
"He's trying to build a picture of you," she said quietly.
"I wanted you to know."
I called Patricia immediately.
"He's trying to establish a counter-narrative," Patricia said.
"He needs to redirect from fraud to character." She paused.
"It tells me he's scared.
Scared people get reckless.
When he gets reckless, he makes mistakes.
And when he makes mistakes, we're ready."
"How do we get ready?"
"I need every person in your corner," she said.
"Anyone who can speak to your parenting, your character, your mental stability during the marriage.
I want statements.
I want names."
I thought about Diane.
About Janet.
May you like
About the other mothers at school pickup who had watched me carry a baby on my hip through the first year after the divorce without once failing to show up.
"I know exactly who to call," I said.