Chapter 4: What Alexander Actually Was
We moved inside while Rebecca Marsh spoke quietly with Thomas near the gate.
My sister Janet had already corralled the younger children into the kitchen with snacks and noise, bless her.
My son, Ethan, had not moved.
He sat on the edge of a deck chair with his arms on his knees, staring at the ground.
I touched his shoulder as I passed and he didn't pull away, which I took as the best I could hope for right now.
Alexander followed me into the hallway.
I closed the door behind us.
"Tell me," I said.
He looked at me for a moment, measuring something.
Then he sat down on the bottom stair and clasped his hands together and told me the truth.
"Martin Hale hired the agency eight months ago.
Not to find a fake girlfriend.
To build a documentation case against Thomas.
Financial irregularities, undisclosed assets, misrepresentation during your divorce mediation.
Martin had the records but he needed them assembled correctly, verified, and delivered at the right moment."
"And the acting agency?"
"I do work for the agency.
That part wasn't a lie.
But I'm also a licensed private investigator.
The agency has a partnership arrangement.
Some assignments require both skill sets." He paused.
"When Martin heard you had contacted the agency looking for someone to help you feel less alone at your son's birthday party, he made a request.
He wanted the delivery made at a moment when Thomas was comfortable.
Off guard.
Surrounded by witnesses."
I sat down on the step beside him because my legs had run out of their willingness to hold me upright.
"You used me," I said.
Not angrily.
Just plainly.
"Martin wanted to protect you," Alexander said.
"And yes — he needed a vehicle to get Thomas into the right position.
But those two things are not mutually exclusive." He looked at me directly.
"Claire.
That man hid over a quarter of a million dollars from you during your divorce.
He called you ugly in front of your children's friends.
He brought the woman he cheated on you with to your son's birthday party.
Martin wanted him to face that in public, with documentation, with a witness, with no warning.
And he wanted you to be the one holding the paper when it happened."
I looked at my hands.
The statement was still in them.
"Does it matter," Alexander said quietly, "that the plan existed?
Or does it matter what the plan exposed?"
Outside, through the window, I could see Thomas with his phone pressed to his ear.
His jaw was tight.
He was pacing a small circle near the garden wall.
Sophie stood apart from him now, arms crossed, staring at something in the middle distance.
She wasn't touching him anymore.
She wasn't even looking at him.
"He's trying to reach someone who will help him," I said.
"He won't find them today."
"And tomorrow?"
Alexander was quiet for a beat.
"Rebecca Marsh has been building this case for eight months.
She's thorough.
Thomas can lawyer up and he will.
But the documentation is clean and it's already in the right hands."
"What does that mean for me?"
"It means your divorce settlement was based on fraudulent disclosure.
It means you are entitled to reopen the proceedings.
It means Thomas committed fraud." He paused.
"It also means you have a decision to make.
About whether you want to pursue it."
I hadn't thought about that yet.
The decision.
All of this had fallen on me in the last twenty minutes and I had not yet reached the part where I had to choose anything.
I had only been surviving.
"How much time do I have?"
"Rebecca will want to speak with you today, if possible.
Nothing is filed yet.
Everything depends on your direction."
I stood up.
Through the glass, Thomas caught my eye.
He stopped pacing.
For a long second neither of us moved.
Then he started toward the door.
"He's coming in," I said.
Alexander stood up beside me.
May you like
"Let him," he said.
The door handle turned.