Chapter 4: The Friend With the Phone

Her name was Cassidy Marsh, and she had not left the lawn.
I had expected her to disappear the moment the afternoon went sideways.
That is what people do when they have been caught holding evidence of something they should not have been doing.
They find a reason to leave, and then they are simply gone, and you spend the next several weeks reconstructing what they saw from the gap their absence leaves behind.
But Cassidy Marsh was still there, sitting alone at one of the white iron tables near the rose trellis, her phone face-down in front of her and a glass of sparkling water she had not touched.
She was twenty-eight or twenty-nine, dressed more carefully than the occasion required, and she had the watchful stillness of someone waiting to find out whether the thing they had set in motion was going to land the way they had planned.
I walked toward her alone.
Daniel had wanted to come.
I had told him no.
She looked up when I reached the table, and her expression went through three things very quickly: recognition, calculation, and then a version of composure that did not quite reach her eyes.
"Mind if I sit?" I said.
She minded.
She gestured at the chair across from her anyway.
I sat down, folded my hands on the table, and let the silence run for a few seconds.
Old habit.
In a courtroom, silence belongs to whoever is not afraid of it.
Cassidy reached for her water glass and then stopped.
"I wasn't filming anything important," she said.
"You were filming all afternoon," I said.
"That's a choice, not a reflex."
"People film parties."
"People film parties to remember them," I said.
"You were filming me specifically.
The angle was low and deliberate, and it started before Elle came near me.
That means you knew what was going to happen."
Her jaw tightened.
"I don't know what you think you saw."
"I think I saw someone documenting an incident they had advance knowledge of," I said.
"I think I saw someone who was hoping the footage would be useful afterward.
The question I have is useful to whom."
She looked at the table.
"Cassidy." I kept my voice even.
"I spent four decades watching people decide whether to tell the truth or dig themselves deeper.
You are currently digging.
I would like to give you the opportunity to stop."
Her hand moved to her phone and then away again.
"He said it would just be a joke," she said finally.
"He said she'd bump into you, you'd spill something, it would be embarrassing, and the video would just be — he called it insurance."
"Who said that?"
She pressed her lips together.
"The text that was sent to my clerk's phone," I said.
"Was that you?"
Her head came up fast.
"What text?"
She wasn't performing.
The surprise was real.
"Someone sent a message to Daniel Osei's phone in the last fifteen minutes," I said.
"It suggested I should be careful about the reach of my verdicts."
Cassidy stared at me.
The composure was completely gone now.
"That wasn't me," she said.
"I filmed because — I was told the video was for Elle.
To show her later.
He said she'd think it was funny."
"Who told you that?"
She picked up her phone and turned it over.
Her hands were not steady.
She opened her messages, scrolled, and held the screen toward me without saying anything.
The name at the top of the thread was not Garrett Ruffin.
May you like
It was a name I had not heard in eleven years, and the last time I had heard it, I was reading a verdict aloud in a courtroom in the fourth-floor federal building downtown.
The name was Warren Lyle.