Spotlight

Chapter 3: What Daniel Handed Me

My clerk's name was Daniel Osei, and I had hired him twenty-three years ago because he was the only applicant who had argued back at me during his interview.

He had been right, and I had hired him on the spot.

He led me away from the stone path, away from Elle and her dripping dress and her friend with the suddenly dead phone, and he walked me to the far end of the lawn where the hedge met the lake wall and the noise of the party felt very far away.

He reached inside his jacket and took out an envelope.

It was a standard legal envelope, cream-colored, already open.

"Her father sent this to me last week," Daniel said.

"I didn't know what to do with it until about ten minutes ago."

I took the envelope and looked at him.

"What is it?"

"Read the top page first."

I pulled out the papers.

The top page was a letter, handwritten on personal stationery.

The name at the bottom was Garrett Ruffin.

I knew that name.

Garrett Ruffin had appeared before me twice.

Once in a civil matter involving a property dispute that his company had manufactured deliberately to drive out a smaller competitor.

Once in a contempt hearing where he had sent his attorney to answer for conduct he should have answered for himself.

Both times I had ruled against him.

Both times he had walked out of my courtroom with the particular stillness of a man who was not accustomed to losing and had not yet decided what to do about it.

I read the letter.

It was three paragraphs.

The first explained that his daughter would be attending Daniel's gathering.

The second asked Daniel, in the careful language of a man who does not make direct requests, to ensure that the afternoon passed without incident.

The third paragraph was the one that made me read it twice.

*She has been struggling.

I will not pretend otherwise.

I have been trying to find the right help for some time.

I would consider it a personal kindness if you could keep an eye on her today and call me if anything goes wrong.*

I looked up from the letter.

"He knew she would do something," I said.

"I think he was hoping the environment would settle her down." Daniel's voice was careful.

"I don't think he anticipated the specific direction."

"Has he done this before?

Asked people to watch her?"

"That's the second page."

I turned to the second page.

It was a printed email chain, forwarded to Daniel from an address I didn't recognize.

Four messages.

Two from Garrett Ruffin.

Two from a woman named Patricia Holt, who identified herself in the signature line as a behavioral health coordinator at a private clinic in Connecticut.

The emails were from eight months ago.

Garrett Ruffin had been trying to arrange an evaluation for his daughter.

Patricia Holt had responded twice with intake paperwork.

Garrett Ruffin had gone quiet after the second response.

The clinic paperwork had never been returned.

I set the pages back in the envelope and held it in both hands.

"Elle's friend filmed this afternoon deliberately," I said.

"That wasn't impulsive.

Someone told her to have a phone ready."

Daniel nodded slowly.

"That occurred to me too."

"Does Garrett Ruffin know what happened today?"

"Not yet." Daniel glanced back toward the lawn.

"Elle hasn't called him.

She's been sitting at the bar for the last five minutes not touching her drink."

I looked at the envelope in my hands.

"What do you want to do?" Daniel asked.

"I want to know who told the friend to film it," I said.

"And I want to know why."

Daniel's phone buzzed in his jacket pocket.

He looked at the screen, and something in his face shifted.

"It's a number I don't recognize," he said.

"Text message."

He turned the phone so I could read it.

*Tell the judge she should be careful.

Some verdicts have a longer reach than she thinks.*

May you like

The lake was very still behind us.

The dog down the hill had stopped barking.

Related Stories

Other posts