Chapter 7: The One Before My Mother

Her name was Diane Osterfeld.
She lived forty minutes north, in a town called Millhaven.
She was seventy-one years old and she had lost her husband two years before my father passed.
Ryan had met her through a church grief group.
Carol told us this with her tea going cold in front of her, her voice steady in the way voices get when someone has been rehearsing what to say for a very long time.
"He was with her for almost eight months," Carol said.
"Handyman things at first.
Then errands.
Then he was there every day.
Then he was there most nights." She looked at her hands.
"I didn't know the details then.
We weren't together at the time.
I only found out later when he came back to me and let some of it slip."
"What happened with Diane?" I asked.
"She signed something.
I don't know exactly what.
A power of attorney, maybe, or something like your mother's document.
By the time her daughter found out and got involved, Ryan had already moved money out of a joint account Diane had added him to." Carol paused.
"The daughter threatened to go to the police.
Ryan gave some of it back.
Not all.
The daughter decided not to push it because Diane didn't want the embarrassment."
My mother was very quiet across the table.
"He found grieving women," I said.
Carol nodded.
"Women who were lonely.
Women who trusted him because he was patient and he was warm and he showed up when no one else did." She looked at my mother.
"Linda, I'm sorry.
I should have said something when he asked me to come here and be a witness.
I should have asked more questions.
I believed what he told me."
My mother nodded slowly.
She didn't speak.
"Do you have any way to reach Diane?" I asked.
"Or her daughter?"
"Her daughter is named Pam.
I have a number somewhere.
It's old, but—" Carol pulled out her phone and scrolled.
"Here."
I copied it into my own phone.
"Is there anyone else you know of?" I asked.
"Anyone besides Diane and my mother?"
Carol hesitated.
Just briefly.
But it was there.
"There was a woman in Calverton," she said.
"I don't have details.
Just a name he mentioned once — Margaret.
He laughed about it.
Said she'd been easy." Carol's jaw tightened.
"I told myself he was just talking.
Being a man.
I told myself a lot of things for a long time."
I called Patricia that afternoon.
I told her about Diane.
I told her about Carol's willingness to provide a statement.
Patricia's voice changed.
Not louder.
Sharper.
"A pattern of behavior across multiple victims," she said, "changes this from a civil dispute to something the DA's office will want to look at.
If Diane's daughter will corroborate, and if Carol puts her account in writing, you don't just have a fraud case.
You have a predatory pattern."
"What does that mean for my mother's house?"
"It means the title transfer becomes much easier to vacate.
Courts do not look kindly on documented predatory conduct against grieving widows." A pause.
"Jessica, how quickly can you get me Carol's written statement?"
"Tomorrow morning."
"Good.
And call Pam."
I called Pam Osterfeld that evening.
She answered on the third ring, cautious and quiet.
I told her my name and why I was calling.
May you like
There was a silence on the line.
Then she said: "I've been waiting two years for someone to say that name to me."