Spotlight

Chapter 11: Margaret

It took a week to find her.

Pam had a mutual contact who knew someone in Calverton, and eventually a name came back to us.

Margaret Tolliver.

Seventy-four.

Widowed three years ago.

Lived alone in a house on the east side of town, maintained a small garden, attended a Thursday morning watercolor class.

She hadn't told anyone.

I drove to Calverton alone on a Tuesday.

I found the house — pale yellow, tidy, a row of late-season asters still going along the front walk.

I knocked.

She answered in a cardigan and reading glasses, holding a crossword.

"Mrs.

Tolliver," I said.

"My name is Jessica.

I'm not here to sell you anything or ask for anything.

I'm here because I think someone hurt you the same way he hurt my mother."

She looked at me for a long moment.

"Ryan Calloway," she said.

"Yes."

She opened the door wider and stepped aside.

The story was familiar in its bones and different in its details.

Ryan had met her through a neighbor.

He'd done repairs.

He'd been kind.

He'd been patient.

He'd said the right things at the right moments and waited for her to trust him completely before he'd put anything in front of her to sign.

What she'd signed was a power of attorney.

She hadn't understood it was a power of attorney.

She thought it was a medical directive — that's what he'd called it, a just-in-case document, something her doctor would recommend.

It had authorized him to act on her behalf in all financial matters.

He'd used it once: to transfer forty-three thousand dollars from her savings account to an account she'd never heard of.

Then he'd disappeared.

Moved on.

She'd found out four months later when she went to pay her insurance and the account was nearly empty.

"I was ashamed," she said.

We were sitting at her kitchen table.

She was holding her crossword folded in half in her lap.

"I'm a grown woman.

I'm not a fool.

And I let him walk in here and I—" She stopped.

Pressed her lips together.

"He was practiced," I said.

"He knew what to say to make it feel safe."

"I know that.

I tell myself that." She looked up.

"It doesn't stop the shame."

"No," I said.

"It doesn't.

But it might help to know you're the third person we've found.

And we think there may be more."

She was quiet for a moment.

"What do you need from me?"

"A written statement.

And your permission to give your contact information to a woman at the DA's office named Sherri Laine."

Margaret set down her crossword.

Smoothed her cardigan.

Sat up slightly.

"I have the bank records," she said.

"I kept everything.

I didn't know what I was going to do with them, but I kept them."

She brought a small box from the back bedroom.

Inside it were two years of bank statements, the original power of attorney document, and a handwritten log she'd made in the months after she'd discovered the transfers.

Dates, amounts, the few things Ryan had said to her in the days before he left.

I sat in her kitchen for two hours.

I left with photographs of every page.

When I got back to my car, I sat for a moment in the quiet.

Three women.

Three sets of documents.

Three versions of the same careful, patient performance.

I called Patricia.

"I found Margaret," I said.

"She has the records."

"How complete?"

"Complete enough."

Patricia let out a long breath.

"Then we have the pattern.

Not implied.

May you like

Documented." A pause.

"I'm calling Sherri tonight."

Related Stories

Other posts