I heard Lily's muffled cry before I reached the study.

Marlene was sentenced to six years.

Her solicitor appealed.

The appeal was denied four months later.

I read the single-paragraph news report on my phone while waiting for Lily's school to let out, standing at the gate in the November cold with the other parents, and then I put my phone in my pocket and waited.

The doors opened.

Lily came out in a rush of small bodies, spotted me, and ran.

She had made something at school.

She pressed it into my hands before I could say hello — a folded piece of card, slightly crumpled at one corner.

I opened it.

Inside was a drawing.

A woman with yellow hair standing in a garden.

Beside her, a tall figure and a small one.

Above them all, the yellow circle she always drew in the corner — not the sun.

Never the sun.

Underneath, in her careful six-year-old handwriting, she had written: *We are okay now.*

I folded it back up and put it in my coat pocket.

"Good day?" I asked.

"Medium," she said, taking my hand.

"We did fractions.

I don't like fractions."

"Nobody likes fractions."

"Did you do anything today?"

"A few things."

We walked to the car.

She talked about fractions and about a girl at school who had a new lunchbox and about a robin she'd seen on the playground fence.

I listened to all of it.

At home, I made pasta — her choice — and we ate at the kitchen table with the radio on low.

After dinner she did her reading and I washed up, and when I came to say goodnight she was already half asleep with the picture book open across her chest.

I took the book and set it on the nightstand.

"Dad," she said, not quite asleep.

"Yeah, bug."

"Is Grandma going to come back?"

I sat on the edge of her bed.

"Not for a long time.

And when she does, things will be different.

I'll make sure of that."

She thought about this.

"Okay," she said.

Then: "Stephen's nice."

"He is."

"Is he going to visit again?"

"I think so.

If you want him to."

"I do." A pause.

"He has the same nose as you."

"I know."

She closed her eyes.

I sat there until her breathing slowed and steadied.

Then I went downstairs and took the folded card out of my coat pocket and set it on the kitchen counter where I could see it.

*We are okay now.*

I made tea.

Stood at the window while the kettle boiled.

The garden was dark, and the yellow circle was nowhere — just the ordinary night sky, just the ordinary stars.

But I thought about Claire.

About the third date and the bad wine and the sticky menus.

About her hand in mine across the table.

About the way she'd said *you're the first person who didn't flinch* — and how I hadn't understood then what a weight she'd been carrying, or how long she'd been carrying it alone.

She had tried to give me the truth.

She had walked toward it even when someone told her it would cost everything.

It had.

And it had found its way to me anyway.

Through a purse on a desk chair.

Through a six-year-old who pointed.

Through a daughter who knew, even at four, the difference between angry-crying and sad-crying.

I poured the tea.

Sat down at the table where Lily had drawn her picture.

Outside, somewhere down the street, a door closed gently.

I didn't mind the quiet.

---