Chapter 6: The Man at the Door

It wasn't Victor.
It was a woman I'd never seen before — mid-forties, neat dark coat, a leather document case under one arm.
She looked at me with the specific, practiced calm of someone who delivered difficult news professionally.
"Are you the current occupant of this property?" she asked.
"I'm the legal guardian of the residents," I said.
"Who are you?"
She held out a card.
"My name is Patricia Holt.
I'm a solicitor.
I've been asked to deliver a formal notice regarding a contested property claim." She glanced past me.
"I'd like to come in."
Robert appeared at my shoulder.
"Who instructed you?"
She looked at him.
"My client is Mr.
Victor Hartley."
Robert stepped back and held the door open.
"Come in, Ms.
Holt."
She sat at the kitchen table and opened her document case with the composed efficiency of someone who did this every day.
She placed a stack of papers in front of me.
I didn't touch them.
"Mr.
Hartley is filing a formal challenge to the trust arrangement established by Grace and Daniel Marsh prior to their deaths," she said.
"His position is that the arrangement was executed under duress and without proper independent legal counsel, and therefore may not be fully enforceable."
"Under duress," I repeated.
"That is his claim, yes."
"Grace and Daniel were alive and healthy when they executed that document," Robert said.
"There was no duress."
"Mr.
Hartley's position is that his cousin was under emotional pressure related to a previous incident and that the arrangement may not reflect her settled intentions."
"What previous incident?" I asked.
Ms.
Holt looked at me steadily.
"Mr.
Hartley alleges that in the months before her d*ath, Grace Marsh confided in him that she had concerns about the suitability of the named guardian."
The room went very still.
"Concerns," I said.
"That is his claim."
"What kind of concerns?"
"He has not provided specific documentation at this stage.
He intends to present a full statement in proceedings."
Lucas made a sharp sound from across the kitchen.
"That's not true."
"I'm required to deliver the notice, not evaluate its contents," Ms.
Holt said.
She was not unkind about it.
She looked at me directly.
"I should tell you — and this is off the record as professional courtesy — that this type of claim is very difficult to establish after thirteen years, particularly when the named guardian has been in continuous occupation and has fulfilled all legal obligations of guardianship without challenge."
"Then why is he filing it?" Robert asked.
She closed her document case.
"In my experience, Mr.
Hartley's type files claims not to win them, but to pressure a settlement." She stood.
"I would strongly recommend securing independent legal representation today."
She left her card on the table and walked out.
The front door clicked shut behind her.
Ethan picked up the card and turned it over.
Then he set it down and looked at me.
"He's going to say Grace didn't trust you," he said.
"Yes."
"He's going to say she told him things she never put in writing."
"Yes."
"And we're supposed to prove she didn't."
Robert shook his head.
"We don't have to prove she didn't.
We have to show what she actually did.
The letter.
The trust document.
Thirteen years of receipts, school records, medical appointments, and a legal guardianship that was never once challenged in court." He looked at me.
"Do you have records?"
"I kept everything," I said.
"Every document.
Every school report.
Every medical form.
I have three full binders."
Ethan let out a slow breath.
"Because of course you do."
It wasn't sarcasm.
It sounded almost like relief.
My phone buzzed on the table.
Unknown number.
I answered on speaker.
"I think we should talk," Victor said.
May you like
"Just the two of us.
Before this gets ugly."