Chapter 5: Victor

I didn't sleep that night.
Robert stayed.
He took the couch without asking and without making a production of it, and by the time the house settled into silence around two in the morning, I was sitting at the kitchen table alone with Grace's letter and a cold cup of tea.
I read it four more times.
She had written about the boys — small things, specific things.
That Ethan cried at films but only if no one was watching.
That Lucas had a habit of collecting smooth stones from wherever he went and keeping them in his coat pocket.
That they both had their father's stubbornness and her tendency to apologize after the fact rather than before.
She had written about me.
About the afternoon she'd watched me from the kitchen window, sitting on the back porch with both boys after a bad day at school, not saying anything, just being there.
*That's the kind of person you are,* she had written.
*You don't perform comfort.
You just provide it.*
I folded the letter and put it back in the envelope.
In the morning, Robert made coffee, and we sat across from each other while the boys slept.
He told me about Victor.
The name felt too small for the shape of the damage.
"He was always at the edge of things," Robert said.
"Grace and Daniel's wedding, the holidays, every family event — always there, always pleasant, always paying attention to exactly the wrong things.
When Daniel died, Victor was the first one through the door."
"I remember him," I said.
"He came to the house once, the month after the funeral.
I'd never met him before.
He said he was checking in on the boys."
"What did he do?"
"He walked through the house," I said slowly.
"I thought he was just — I thought he was grieving.
He opened a few doors.
Asked how much I was paying in utilities."
Robert nodded.
"He was assessing."
"I asked him to leave."
"Good."
"He called me overprotective on his way out."
Robert's expression didn't change, but his coffee cup went down harder than necessary.
"He filed a claim on the estate six weeks after the accident.
Argued that as Grace's nearest living adult relative, he had a right to guardianship of the boys and control of the property."
"I had no idea," I said.
"The court rejected it.
Your guardianship was already established, and the trust arrangement held.
But he never let it go." Robert looked at the window.
"Some people are like that.
They decide something belongs to them, and they just — wait.
They're patient.
They let time do the work."
Ethan appeared in the doorway.
He was dressed, which meant he hadn't slept either.
"I want to call Victor," he said.
Robert and I both looked at him.
"I want to ask him directly," Ethan said.
"I want to hear what he says."
"He'll lie," Robert said.
"I know.
But I want to hear how he lies." Ethan pulled out his chair and sat down.
"He came to us three weeks ago.
He took us to dinner.
He was — he was generous.
He said he'd been thinking about us for years and felt guilty for not being more present.
He said he wanted to do right by us now that we were adults." His voice was flat.
"He said you'd taken advantage of a legal grey area and that the house was rightfully ours and that we deserved to know the truth."
"And it didn't feel wrong?" I asked.
Not accusatory — genuinely asking.
Ethan was quiet for a moment.
"It felt wrong the whole time," he said.
"I think I knew it felt wrong and I didn't want to know why.
Because if something was wrong with Victor's story, then we'd done something wrong to you.
And that was—" He stopped.
"That was harder to sit with."
The kitchen was quiet for a long moment.
Lucas appeared behind him.
He had Grace's eyes, something I'd always known but which hit me differently this morning.
"What do we do?" Lucas asked.
Robert put both hands flat on the table.
"Victor is going to contact you again.
Probably today.
When he does, don't tell him anything.
Don't confirm or deny.
Just listen." He paused.
"Can you do that?"
Both boys nodded.
May you like
The front doorbell rang.
It was seven-fourteen in the morning.