Chapter 3: Three Words and a Number He Didn't Know

Daniel read the message twice.
*Ask her why.*
He looked up at Vanessa.
She was dabbing her eyes with the edge of her sleeve, speaking softly to herself about how stressful the afternoon had been, how she hadn't meant for any of it to happen.
He said nothing.
He walked to his study, closed the door, and called the number back.
It rang four times.
Then a man's voice.
"I wondered if you'd call."
"Who is this?"
"Someone who worked for Vanessa Cole about eighteen months ago." A pause.
"Someone she had fired after she accused him of stealing a watch."
Daniel sat down slowly.
"What's your name?"
"Marcus Webb.
I was her personal driver.
Before you, she was engaged to a man named Gerald Holt.
Shipping money, older.
Very trusting." Another pause.
"Does that sound familiar?"
"Keep talking."
"She accused me of taking a cufflink.
One cufflink.
The kind that doesn't even have a pair anymore.
Gerald believed her.
I was let go without a reference." Marcus's voice was steady, practiced, like a man who had rehearsed this conversation many times and never expected to have it.
"Three weeks later, Gerald's personal assistant was accused of taking a ring.
She was let go too."
Daniel's hand tightened around the phone.
"And Gerald?"
"Married Vanessa six months after that.
Divorced her fourteen months later.
She walked away with a settlement I'm not legally allowed to discuss, but I can tell you it was significant enough that Gerald sold his lake house to cover it."
The room felt very still.
"Why are you telling me this now?"
"Because I saw the engagement announcement in the Charlotte Observer last month," Marcus said.
"And because I've been waiting for someone to pick up when I called."
"How many times have you called?"
"You're the first."
Daniel set the phone down on the desk without ending the call.
He looked at the wall.
Then he picked it back up.
"Can you prove any of this?"
"I kept everything," Marcus said.
"Every message she sent me after I was fired.
Every email Gerald's attorney sent threatening to pursue the theft claim.
I kept it all because I knew someday I'd need it."
"Send it to me."
"I'll need an address."
"Use my office." Daniel gave it.
"And Marcus — don't contact Vanessa.
Don't tell anyone you called me."
"I've waited eighteen months," Marcus said.
"I can wait a little longer."
The call ended.
Daniel sat in the quiet of his study for a long moment.
Through the closed door, he could hear Vanessa on the phone in the hallway, her voice warm and easy again, laughing at something one of her friends had said.
He thought about Gerald Holt's lake house.
He thought about Grace's folded hands and familiar-tired eyes.
He thought about the bracelet sitting in the bowl by the door — the bowl that was six feet from the table where Vanessa claimed it had been.
Then he opened his laptop and typed Gerald Holt Charlotte NC into the search bar.
The results came back in seconds.
Gerald Holt was not difficult to find.
He had a profile on a business networking site, a modest import consultancy, and a listed phone number through his company.
Daniel wrote it down.
He did not call it that night.
But he did not delete it either.
When he came out of the study, Vanessa was in the kitchen doorway, two glasses of wine in her hands, her smile warm and practiced and perfectly timed.
"I thought we could have a quiet evening," she said.
"Just us.
I'm sorry about today.
I really am."
Daniel took the glass.
"Tell me about your last relationship," he said.
Vanessa's smile didn't move.
But something behind her eyes did.
"Why do you ask?"
"I'm curious," Daniel said.
"We've been together two years and I realize I don't know much about who you were before me."
She tilted her head slightly.
"There's not much to tell.
A few relationships that didn't work out.
Nothing serious."
"No one you were engaged to?"
The pause was less than a second.
Most people would not have caught it.
Daniel caught it.
"No," Vanessa said.
"No one I was engaged to."
She touched his arm and steered him gently toward the sitting room.
Daniel followed.
May you like
And said nothing more that night.
But in his jacket pocket, Gerald Holt's phone number was already written down.