Spotlight

Chapter 9: What Patricia Said Outside the Door

The story ran on a Thursday.

By Friday morning, there were forty-seven comments on the newspaper's website.

By Friday afternoon, the school board had issued a statement saying they were taking the matter "extremely seriously." By Saturday, two other board members had called publicly for Patricia Holloway to recuse herself from any proceedings involving her daughter.

She did not recuse herself.

She showed up to the formal disciplinary hearing on Monday in the same kind of blazer, with the same leather folder, with a lawyer of her own who kept objecting to procedural points that Carol batted away one by one like they were nothing.

Jade was not in the room.

She was represented by a written statement.

Marcus Brennan's parents were there.

Sandra held the folder on her lap with both hands.

Alyssa sat next to me and said nothing.

She didn't need to.

Her recorded audio was played through a small speaker on the conference table, and when Jade's voice came through — bright and certain and laughing — the room did what rooms do when something undeniable enters them.

It went very still.

The hearing lasted four hours.

At the end, the board voted on the findings.

Patricia sat at the table with her lawyer and watched the hands go up.

I counted them.

Five to two.

She gathered her folder.

Her lawyer said something quietly into her ear.

She stood, and I expected her to leave without looking at me.

She didn't.

She walked across the room and stopped in front of me, just outside the door, while Alyssa and Carol were gathering their things behind me.

Up close, she looked different from the woman who had sat on my sofa.

The smoothness was still there — it probably never fully left — but underneath it now was something rawer, something she hadn't planned to let me see.

"I didn't know what Jade did," she said.

Very quietly.

Not loud enough for anyone else to hear.

"I want you to know that.

I didn't know the specifics until after Emma — until after.

What I did was try to protect my daughter without knowing the full truth of what she had done.

That was wrong.

I know it was wrong."

I looked at her.

"Your daughter came to an adult at that school," I said.

"She did everything right.

She asked for help.

And she was failed by every adult in that building who was more worried about themselves than about her." I held her gaze.

"Including you.

Because the moment you walked into my house to threaten me, you chose your position over Emma's life.

And you will have to carry that."

Patricia's jaw moved.

No words came.

I stepped around her and walked out.

Carol caught up with me in the parking lot.

"They'll be moving to remove her from the board," she said.

"The two who voted against the findings are already isolated.

It's a matter of time."

Alyssa walked beside me to the car.

The autumn air was sharp and cold and completely clear.

She didn't say anything until we were inside with the doors closed.

"Is it over?" she asked.

"Almost," I said.

She looked out the windshield.

"Mom.

I'm sorry I hid the backpack.

I'm sorry every single day."

I put the car in drive.

May you like

"I know, baby," I said.

"I know."

Related Stories

Other posts