Spotlight

Chapter 7: The Morning Alyssa Didn't Stay Quiet

The lawyer's name was Carol Reyes.

She had a small office above a dry cleaner on the main street, and a filing system that looked catastrophic but apparently worked, because she found the right forms within thirty seconds of us sitting down.

She listened to everything without interrupting.

She looked at the notebook.

She looked at the bottle in the sealed bag.

She played the recording once, all the way through, and when it ended, she set Alyssa's phone face-down on the desk.

"I want you to be very clear about something," she said.

"This recording may or may not be legally admissible depending on the state's consent laws.

But paired with the medical examiner's toxicology report — which you are entitled to request — and the school counselor's own admission to you, what you have is a pattern.

And patterns are what cases are built on."

"What kind of case?" I asked.

"At minimum, a formal complaint to the school board that cannot be swept under a rug because the board member's daughter is involved — in fact, that conflict of interest works in your favor." She leaned forward.

"And potentially a civil action depending on what the toxicology shows."

"How long will this take?"

"Longer than you want it to.

But here's what I'd like to do immediately — file the formal complaint this week, before Patricia Holloway has time to build any kind of defensive structure around herself or the school."

We left her office with a plan.

Three days later, the complaint was filed.

Two days after that, I got a call from the school principal, Dr.

Okafor.

He asked me to come in with Alyssa for what he called a "clarifying conversation."

We sat across from Dr.

Okafor and the vice principal in a conference room with a long table.

Patricia Holloway was not there.

But her fingerprints were all over the room.

"Alyssa," Dr.

Okafor began gently, "I want to understand what you witnessed.

I know this is very hard.

But I need to ask you some questions about the recording."

Alyssa looked at him.

Then she looked at me.

"You can answer," I said.

She turned back to Dr.

Okafor and folded her hands on the table.

"Jade gave Emma a pill," she said clearly.

"She told her it was a supplement.

It wasn't.

She told her it would help her on the test.

She laughed about it afterward on the recording, which I have.

I told Emma not to take it.

Emma took it anyway because she was exhausted from being tormented every single day and she just wanted it to stop." Her voice did not waver.

"I hid the backpack because I was scared.

That was wrong, and I know it.

But everything I just told you is the truth."

The vice principal shifted in her seat.

Dr.

Okafor looked at Alyssa for a long moment.

Then he looked at me.

"Mrs.

Davis," he said carefully, "I want you to know that the school's priority is—"

"I know what your priority is," I said.

"I want to know what you're going to do about Jade Holloway."

He hesitated.

"Dr.

Okafor." Alyssa's voice cut through the room.

"Emma came to Mr.

Hart.

He wrote it in a file and did nothing.

If someone had done something — anything — my sister might still be here." She leaned forward slightly.

"Are you going to do something?

Or are you going to write it in a file too?"

The room went very quiet.

The vice principal looked at her hands.

Dr.

Okafor picked up his pen.

Set it down again.

"We will be initiating a full review," he said.

"Starting today."

Walking out to the car, Alyssa didn't say anything for a long moment.

Then she looked at me across the roof of the car before we got in.

"Did I do okay?"

"You were extraordinary," I told her.

She got in.

May you like

I got in.

And for the first time since I'd pulled that backpack out from under her bed, she let me reach over and hold her hand without pulling away.

Related Stories

Other posts