Chapter 10: The Reckoning

The formal complaint against Stuart Phipps was accepted by the Arizona Bar three weeks after Janet filed it.
The Maricopa County Sheriff's Office opened a criminal investigation two days after that.
Janet called me on a Tuesday morning while I was feeding Lily breakfast.
"They executed a search warrant on Phipps's office yesterday," she said.
"They pulled client files, financial records, and his correspondence with Derek going back four years."
"Four years," I said.
"That's before my father."
"Yes.
There are at least five families now.
Possibly more.
The detective handling it thinks Phipps has been running this scheme for closer to six years, but the earlier cases may be harder to prove." She paused.
"Derek's financial records are also being subpoenaed.
The property management company in Scottsdale is under review."
"When will we know about the will?"
"The probate court has scheduled a hearing for the twenty-second.
I've submitted your birth certificate, your father's statement, and the declarations from the Mesa and Tempe families.
I've also submitted a forensic document analysis — the signature on the amended will shows pressure inconsistencies with your father's other signatures from the same period."
"Meaning someone guided his hand."
"Meaning it's possible.
The analyst won't go further than that without more samples, but it's in the record." She paused.
"Claire, I want to be honest with you.
The will contest is strong.
The property recovery is harder and will take longer.
Derek structured the transfers through enough layers that unwinding them is going to be a fight."
"How long?"
"A year.
Maybe eighteen months for full resolution."
I thought about my father in the recliner in Gerald's house.
Six months, the cardiologist had said.
"Can we at least freeze Derek's access to the assets while it's being litigated?"
"I filed for that yesterday.
We should have a ruling within the week."
The ruling came in four days.
Derek's access to my father's remaining financial accounts was frozen pending the outcome of the will contest.
Janet forwarded me the email with one line underneath: *He will not take this quietly.*
She was right.
Derek called my father directly that evening.
Gerald was in the room and heard the whole conversation.
He called me immediately after.
"Derek told your father that you're doing this for the inheritance," Gerald said.
"That you don't actually care about him.
That you're going to put him through a legal ordeal that will kjll him."
I closed my eyes for a second.
"How did Dad respond?"
"He told Derek that he had one living child and that he intended to spend whatever time he had left making things right with her.
And then he hung up."
I didn't say anything for a moment.
"Gerald," I said finally.
"Thank you for being there."
"Where else would I be?" he said simply.
The probate hearing was on a Wednesday morning.
My father appeared by video from Gerald's living room, Janet beside him on screen.
I sat in Janet's conference room in person.
The judge was a woman in her sixties with reading glasses on a chain and the expression of someone who had seen every variation of family cruelty that paperwork could enable.
She read the clause declaring me predeceased.
She looked up over her glasses.
"Ms.
Claire," she said, "you are present today?"
"Yes, Your Honor."
"And you are, in fact, alive."
"Yes, Your Honor."
She looked back at the document.
"The clause is void on its face.
A living person cannot be declared predeceased in a testamentary instrument." She set the will down.
"I'm setting aside the amended will in its entirety pending full review.
The prior will — the one in place before the amendment — is reinstated as the operative document."
She looked at the screen where my father sat.
"Mr.
Harmon," she said, not unkindly.
"I'd recommend getting your own estate attorney to review everything going forward."
"I have one," my father said.
"My daughter found her."
The judge's expression didn't change.
But she nodded once, and I thought I saw something move behind her eyes.
Derek was not present at the hearing.
His attorney was — a man in a gray suit who said very little and wrote a great deal in a small notebook.
As we were leaving, Janet leaned close and said quietly, "His attorney looked nervous."
"Good," I said.
Three days later, Derek's attorney contacted Janet to discuss a settlement.
Janet called me immediately.
"He wants to negotiate," she said.
"What does he want?"
"He wants the criminal investigation to go away.
He's offering to return the property voluntarily in exchange for your family not cooperating with the Sheriff's Office."
I didn't hesitate.
"No."
"I told him you'd say that."
"The other families deserve the same resolution we're getting.
I'm not trading that away."
"Understood." A pause.
"Claire, you should know — when the criminal investigation moves forward, Derek is likely looking at wire fraud, elder financial @buse, and possibly conspiracy charges if they can tie him directly to Phipps's scheme."
"Good," I said.
May you like
"Let it move forward."
It did.