Chapter 4: What Eleanor Said to the Police

The police arrived at half past six.
Two officers.
One in plain clothes who introduced herself as Detective Marsh.
She had a notepad and the particular stillness of someone who had learned to listen before she spoke.
Eleanor met them in the front hallway.
Rosa watched from the doorway of the sitting room, where Grace was still on the sofa, Daniel beside her with his hand on her back.
"This is completely unnecessary," Eleanor said.
Her voice had recovered its composure.
She stood straight, hands clasped in front of her, wearing the expression Rosa had seen her use with contractors and caterers — polite, immovable, faintly contemptuous.
"My daughter-in-law lost her balance near the pool.
It was frightening, I understand that, but accidents happen."
"Ma'am, we'd just like to take a look at the area and ask a few questions," Detective Marsh said.
"Shouldn't take long."
"Of course." Eleanor gestured toward the terrace.
"Help yourself."
She said it the way someone says help yourself to a plate of food they know you won't enjoy.
Detective Marsh and the uniformed officer went outside.
Eleanor turned and walked toward the sitting room.
She stopped in the doorway, looked past Rosa at Grace and Daniel, and arranged her face into something that was almost concern.
"How are you feeling, Grace?
Are the babies moving normally?"
Grace looked at her for a moment.
"Why didn't you call for help?"
"I'm sorry?"
"When I was hanging there.
You were on the balcony.
You saw me." Grace's voice was quiet but it didn't waver.
"Why didn't you call out?
Why didn't you call anyone?"
Eleanor's expression didn't shift.
"I was in shock.
It happened so fast.
By the time I understood what I was seeing, Rosa had already—"
"It wasn't fast," Rosa said.
Eleanor turned to look at her.
The two women held each other's gaze.
"It wasn't fast," Rosa repeated.
"I heard the scream from the pool house.
I ran the length of the terrace.
I dropped to my knees.
I held that cable for long enough that my arms went numb.
You were on that balcony for all of it."
"I don't think I need to explain myself to the housekeeper."
"Rosa." Daniel's voice was even.
"Tell Detective Marsh what you told me.
She'll want to hear it from you directly."
Rosa nodded and walked toward the terrace doors.
As she passed Eleanor, she felt the older woman's hand close around her wrist.
Not hard.
Just enough to stop her.
"Be very careful," Eleanor said softly.
"About what you think you saw."
Rosa looked down at Eleanor's hand.
Then she looked up.
"Let go of my wrist, please."
A beat.
Two beats.
Eleanor released her.
Rosa walked outside.
Detective Marsh was crouching near the cable, the uniformed officer beside her with a small evidence bag already open.
She looked up when Rosa approached.
"You're the one who pulled her back?"
"Yes."
"Can you walk me through exactly what you saw and did?"
Rosa walked her through it.
All of it.
The scream, the sprint, the cable, Grace's hands, her own hands, the burning in her arms, the moment she looked up and saw Eleanor on the balcony.
She kept her voice steady and her account exact.
She did not editorialize.
She did not need to.
Detective Marsh wrote without looking up.
"And Mrs.
Hargrove — the older woman — she made no attempt to assist or call for help during this time."
"None."
"Did she say anything to you from the balcony?"
"Not until after Grace was safe.
Then she said Grace was being dramatic."
The detective's pen paused for just a fraction of a second.
Then it kept moving.
"One more thing," Rosa said.
"Eleanor was on this terrace alone this morning.
Before anyone else was up.
I saw her from the kitchen window around seven.
She was near the cable fixture."
Detective Marsh looked up then.
Really looked at her.
"What time did you see her?"
"Seven fifteen.
Maybe seven twenty."
The detective wrote that down.
She underlined it.
Back inside, Eleanor was seated in the armchair across from Daniel, her attorney already on the phone — Rosa could hear the low murmur of the call from the hallway.
Eleanor watched Rosa come back through the terrace doors.
Her expression had changed in the time Rosa had been outside.
It was the first time Rosa had seen something close to calculation in it.
Not guilt.
Not fear.
Calculation.
That was, in some ways, worse.
Grace shifted on the sofa and made a small sound.
Daniel was on his feet instantly.
"The babies," Grace said.
"Something feels—"
Daniel already had his phone out.
"I'm calling the doctor."
Rosa crossed to Grace and sat beside her, taking her hand the same way Grace had taken hers earlier.
Grace gripped back hard.
May you like
From the armchair, Eleanor watched.
She did not stand up.