Chapter 5: What the Attorney Knew

Christmas morning arrived gray and windless, the snow having finally stopped somewhere around three in the morning and left the street immaculate and silent.
Mara came downstairs to find Graham already at the kitchen table with a coffee cup and a folder of documents open in front of him.
He closed the folder when he heard her on the stairs, which was the kind of thing a person only did if they had been thinking about whether to close it.
"You could have left it open," she said.
"Good morning."
"Did you sleep?"
"Some." He looked at the folder.
Then back at her.
"There are things I need to tell your father.
I wanted to decide how first."
She poured herself coffee and sat down across from him.
"Tell me instead," she said.
"I can take it."
He studied her for a moment.
"You don't know me well enough to make that offer."
"I know you listened to seven horse drawings," she said.
"That buys you something."
He almost smiled.
His hand rested on the folder.
"The property isn't a small parcel," he said.
"It's approximately fourteen acres on the east side of Reeds Lake, including the original cabin.
My grandfather held it in trust for both family lines — the Foster side and the Ellison side — with the provision that it could not be sold without agreement from both.
Patricia — my mother — inherited the Foster interest when her father died.
When she died, it passed to me."
Mara was quiet.
"The Ellison interest," she said slowly.
"That belongs to—"
"Your father."
The kitchen held the sound of the furnace running beneath the floor.
"The property's worth," Graham said carefully, "is not what either of them probably imagined."
"How much?"
He told her.
She set her coffee cup down.
"Alan Weiss isn't a real estate lawyer," she said.
"I heard the name last night."
"He handles estates and trusts.
He's been managing this for three years, since my mother was first diagnosed.
She wanted it settled.
She didn't want it to become a fight the way it was the first time." Graham looked at the folder.
"She left a letter.
Addressed to Robert Ellison.
She wrote it eight months before she d*ed."
Mara looked at him steadily.
"She knew who my father was."
"She found him about four years ago.
Online — it wasn't difficult.
She didn't reach out.
She was afraid of what it would cost both of them emotionally if he didn't want contact." He paused.
"She watched from a distance.
She knew about Owen.
She knew about you." Something shifted in his face.
"She knew about the ladder in the will."
The air went out of the room.
"She read your mother's Facebook page," Graham said, quietly enough that it landed without embarrassment.
"She said it made her feel like she was still part of something."
Mara looked at the window.
The snow on the back porch roof.
The bird feeder her father had put up in October.
"She sent it to you," Mara said.
"The letter."
"Her attorney held it.
With instructions that it be delivered in person, to Robert directly, with me present." He looked at Mara.
"She also left a second letter.
For me.
Explaining why she'd made the choice she made — not to reach out.
She said she was a coward about it and she was sorry." His voice was even.
"She wasn't a coward.
She was someone who had been hurt a long time ago and didn't trust that the door would open."
Mara's throat was tight.
"She wasn't wrong to be afraid," she said.
"But she was wrong about my father."
"I know that now."
Owen's footsteps crossed the ceiling above them.
Mara picked up her coffee cup.
"We need to tell Dad before Owen comes down," she said.
"Owen will want to manage it.
Dad needs to hear it first."
"I know."
She stood.
Then stopped.
"Graham.
The fact that you ended up in that bakery.
The fact that I was the one who walked in."
He looked at her.
"My mother's letter," he said, "references a belief she held.
That if she set the right things in motion and then got out of the way, the right people would find each other." He picked up the folder.
"I'm not a man who believes in that kind of thing."
"But?"
He stood.
"But I was in the bakery," he said.
"And you walked in."
They found Robert in the living room, still in his robe, standing at the window looking out at the snow in the backyard.
He turned when he heard them.
He looked at the folder in Graham's hands and didn't ask.
He just sat down.
And waited for what he'd been waiting for, Mara realized, since the moment he'd seen Graham's face in the hallway.
Graham set the letter on the coffee table.
Robert looked at it for a long moment before picking it up.
His name was written on the front in handwriting that Mara could see, from where she stood, was careful and unhurried — the handwriting of someone who had thought about this letter for a long time before sitting down to write it.
May you like
He opened it.
And Mara watched her father — a man who fixed things with his hands and never cried at movies — begin to cry.