Chapter 4: The Thing About Coincidences

Dinner proceeded the way Ellison dinners always proceeded — loudly, warmly, and with approximately three conversations happening at the same time.
Elaine served the turkey.
Owen carved it badly and refused help.
Claire rescued the gravy.
The children came back downstairs and accepted Graham with the complete indifference of people who had not yet learned to be suspicious of strangers, which is to say they ignored him entirely until Sophie asked whether he wanted to see her drawing of a horse, and when he said yes with apparent sincerity she brought him seven drawings and talked him through each one at considerable length.
He listened to all of it.
Mara watched him from across the table.
He knew how to sit with people.
He didn't perform interest.
He didn't check his phone.
When Jack climbed onto the arm of the couch after dinner to show him something on a handheld game, Graham leaned in and looked at the screen with actual attention.
"You're good with kids," Claire said quietly, appearing beside Mara in the kitchen.
"He's something," Mara said.
"Owen's coming around."
"Owen was born suspicious."
"He's protective." Claire handed her a dish.
"There's a difference."
Owen appeared in the kitchen doorway.
"Graham's asking Dad about the old neighborhood," he said, in the tone of someone reporting an unexpected development.
"Is that bad?" Mara asked.
"No." He picked up a dish towel.
"Dad's laughing."
The three of them stood quietly for a moment with that information.
After dinner, Robert and Graham sat in the chairs by the fire.
Elaine brought coffee and then found reasons to stay nearby — straightening cards on the mantle, refreshing the candles, the small occupations of a woman who wants to hear a conversation without appearing to listen.
Mara sat on the couch with a cup of tea and allowed herself to do the same.
"Patricia kept a photograph," Graham was saying.
"Of her and her father at a lake somewhere.
She said they used to go every summer before everything happened with the estate.
She never said where the lake was."
"Reeds Lake," Robert said.
"Twenty minutes from here.
Our grandfather had a cabin on the east side." He turned his coffee cup in both hands.
"We used to go together, the whole family, before the fight.
Patricia would have been nine or ten the last time."
"She never went back?"
"I don't know.
We didn't speak after." Robert set down the cup.
"I wrote to her father once, about ten years after.
He sent the letter back unopened."
Graham looked at the fire.
"She didn't know that."
"I suspected she didn't."
"She thought the silence was mutual."
Robert said nothing.
"It would have mattered to her," Graham said.
"Knowing you tried."
The fire settled.
A log shifted.
"I should have tried harder," Robert said.
Mara looked down at her tea.
Graham's phone lit up on the arm of his chair.
He glanced at it and turned it face-down without answering.
But Mara had been sitting close enough to see the screen.
ALAN WEISS — ATTORNEY.
He'd seen it.
He'd chosen not to answer.
She didn't say anything.
An hour later, when Owen had taken the children up and Claire had settled into the armchair with a book, Graham stood and said he should call for a car.
"The roads are worse," Mara said.
"I looked."
"I'll manage."
"You said that before.
About the ditch."
The corner of his mouth moved.
"I remember."
"The guest room is made up," Elaine said from the hallway.
Simply, with no surrounding explanation, the way she said things she had already decided.
Graham opened his mouth.
"It's Christmas," Elaine added.
"The roads are bad.
The room is there."
He looked at Mara.
She raised both hands.
"This is not me.
This is my mother, who has never in her life taken no for an answer."
"I heard that," Elaine said.
Graham looked at Robert.
Robert shrugged.
"She's right about the roads.
And the room."
A pause.
"One night," Graham said.
"That's generally how it works," Mara said.
He almost smiled.
"I'm establishing terms."
"Very wise."
He called the attorney back from the hallway, and Mara did not follow, and she did not try to hear.
But twenty minutes later, when she passed the hallway on her way upstairs, he was still on the phone.
His voice was low.
His free hand was pressed flat against the wall.
She caught only one sentence before she was past the doorway.
"How much of it did she know?"
She didn't know who he was asking about.
She didn't know what she'd meant to know.
May you like
But in the morning, she would find out that Alan Weiss was not a real estate attorney.
And that the property in Grand Rapids was not a small parcel at all.