Chapter 6: What Gets Said Over Dinner

The turkey was very good.
Elaine had been cooking since four in the morning, which was a fact she mentioned once and then refused to discuss further, which meant she mentioned it at least three more times over the course of the meal.
The potatoes were right.
The green beans had made it to the table despite everything.
Someone had found the whipped cream for the pie.
For the first twenty minutes, the conversation stayed carefully on the surface.
Owen asked Graham where he'd gone to school.
Graham said Michigan State.
Owen said he'd gone to U of M, and for a moment the room tensed in the particular way that Michigan rooms tense when those two schools are mentioned in the same breath, and then Graham smiled and said his father had been a Michigan State man too, and Owen said that explained several things, and Claire told Owen to behave himself, and just like that the surface held.
Mara watched her father.
Richard ate quietly.
He asked questions at intervals — careful, specific questions.
What Graham did for work.
Civil engineering, it turned out.
Infrastructure.
Bridges, mostly.
He'd been living in Seattle for eleven years.
"What brought you back to Michigan?" Richard asked.
"My mother's house," Graham said.
"She left it to me.
I came back to sort through her things.
I thought it would take a few weeks."
"And?"
Graham looked down at his plate briefly.
"She kept everything.
Every card.
Every photograph.
Every — everything." He paused.
"It takes a long time to go through a life."
Elaine set down her fork.
"She kept your father's things?"
"Yes."
"Even after all those years?"
"She loved him," Graham said simply.
"She never really stopped."
The table was quiet for a moment.
Sophie had been allowed downstairs for dinner on the condition of good behavior, which she interpreted loosely.
She had been watching Graham with the steady, unblinking assessment that only very young children can deploy without embarrassment.
"Are you our cousin?" she asked.
Owen started to say something.
Graham answered before he could.
"Something like that," he said.
Sophie considered this.
"We've never had a cousin before.
Just Marcus, and he's my brother, which is different and also worse."
Marcus threw a green bean at her.
Claire caught it.
Dinner resumed.
It was Richard who shifted things.
Not dramatically.
He set down his fork and looked at Graham and said, simply:
"Tell me about him.
Your father."
Graham looked up.
"What do you want to know?"
"Anything.
Everything." Richard paused.
"I've spent twenty-two years thinking he d*ed before we fixed things.
Tell me who he was."
Graham was quiet for a moment.
Then he started talking.
He talked about a man who got up at five every morning and made coffee strong enough to dissolve a spoon.
A man who could look at a damaged structure and tell you within minutes what had gone wrong and how to fix it.
A man who coached Little League for six years even though Graham had been, by Graham's own admission, a genuinely terrible baseball player.
"He came to every game," Graham said.
"Never once made me feel bad about the score."
Richard's jaw moved.
He picked up his water glass.
"That sounds like him," he said.
"You remember?"
"He used to do that with me." Richard set the glass down.
"When I was learning to drive.
I was — not good at it.
He sat in the passenger seat every time and never once raised his voice."
Graham looked at him.
"He talked about teaching someone to drive," Graham said slowly.
"He never said who."
"He taught me."
The table had gone quiet without anyone deciding to make it quiet.
Owen looked at his father.
Then at Graham.
Then at his wife, who gave him the look that meant: stay still and let it happen.
"He talked about you," Graham said.
"Not by name.
He said he had a brother.
That they'd argued.
That it was the mistake he thought about most."
Richard said nothing.
"He kept a photograph," Graham said.
"Of the two of you.
You looked about twelve and he looked about sixteen.
He had it in his wallet until he d*ed."
A sound came from Richard Ellison that was very small and mostly controlled.
Elaine reached across and put her hand on his arm.
He put his hand over hers.
Graham looked down at his plate.
Mara looked at Sophie, who was watching all of this with wide eyes and the particular solemn expression of a child who understands that something important is happening even if she can't name it.
Marcus had stopped eating.
He was very still.
"I have the photograph," Graham said quietly.
"If you want it."
Richard looked up.
"Yes," he said.
"I want it."
The candles had burned down partway.
The snow outside had stopped.
Through the window, the neighborhood glowed with Christmas lights reflecting off white ground.
Owen cleared his throat.
"So," he said.
His voice was rougher than usual.
"We're having Christmas dinner with our cousin."
"Apparently," Mara said.
"Who you met in a bakery."
"Where he had cold coffee and no phone."
"Which you considered suspicious."
"Extremely."
Graham looked between them.
"Is this how your family always talks to each other?"
"Yes," said Owen, Mara, Richard, and Elaine at the same time.
Graham looked at the table.
At the candles.
At the bowl of potatoes and the plates and the ridiculous amount of food and the seven-year-old who was now stealing his bread roll without any attempt at concealment.
"Sophie," Claire said.
"I'm just looking at it," Sophie said, holding it behind her back.
The laugh that came from Graham was not brief this time.
It was not rusty.
It came out fully, startled out of him, and it filled the room in a way that made Elaine Ellison smile and look away quickly.
Richard watched his nephew laugh.
He picked up his fork.
May you like
"Eat," he said to Graham.
"Before she gets the rest of it."