Spotlight

Chapter 5: What Daniel Wrote

Mara stayed upstairs longer than she needed to.

Sophie had stopped being hungry the moment someone arrived to talk to her, which was predictable.

She wanted to show Mara three specific things she'd found in a closet that she believed were presents for her, and could Mara please look at the shapes and guess what they were, and also was the man downstairs a criminal because her dad had looked at him like he might be.

"He's not a criminal."

"How do you know?"

"I gave him a ride in my car.

Criminals don't accept rides."

Sophie considered this.

"That seems like the opposite of true."

"Go to sleep."

"It's Christmas Eve."

"That's when Santa comes.

Which requires you to be asleep."

Sophie's eyes went wide.

She was seven and still believed, and Mara felt a sudden fierce love for that.

She got both children settled.

The boy — his name was Marcus this week, she'd remembered — fell asleep almost immediately.

Sophie lasted about four more minutes of whispering before she went under too.

Mara sat on the edge of Sophie's bed in the dark and listened to the house.

Voices downstairs.

Low.

Not arguing.

She went down.

The dining room table had been set while she was upstairs.

Her mother had done it quietly, without announcement, the way Elaine Ellison handled most things that needed doing.

The good plates.

The candles.

Six places instead of five.

Graham was in the kitchen doorway with a dish towel over his shoulder, apparently having been handed it by her mother with the same lack of ceremony Elaine applied to everything.

Owen was at the dining room table with a glass of water, not beer.

Claire was helping bring things from the kitchen.

Her father was in the armchair near the window.

The letter was on the side table beside him, refolded, the envelope underneath it.

He was looking at nothing in particular.

Mara crossed the room and sat on the footstool near him.

He looked at her.

"Good?" she asked.

"No," he said.

"Yes.

I don't know yet."

She nodded.

"What did it say?

The letter."

He was quiet for a moment.

"Daniel wrote it in 1987.

He said he'd been trying to find a way back for eight years.

He said he'd picked up the phone a hundred times." A pause.

"He said he was sorry for the argument.

That he'd been wrong.

That he'd been twenty-three years old and too proud and that by the time he understood that, he didn't know if I still wanted to hear it."

"Did you?"

"Of course I did." He looked down at his hands.

"He was my brother."

Mara said nothing.

Sometimes the right thing was to let the sentence sit.

"He wrote about Graham's mother.

About how she was the best thing that had ever happened to him.

He wrote about the day Graham was born." Her father's voice thinned slightly.

"He said he hoped someday I'd meet him.

That he thought I'd like him."

From the kitchen, Graham said something quiet to Claire and Claire laughed — a small, surprised laugh.

Richard looked toward the sound.

"He has Daniel's laugh," he said.

"I didn't notice it at first."

Mara looked toward the kitchen too.

"What was Daniel like?"

Her father considered it.

"Stubborn.

Funnier than me.

Better with his hands.

He could fix anything." A pause.

"He used to drive me to school even when it was out of his way.

Never made a thing of it.

Just did it."

The candles on the table were lit.

The room smelled of turkey and butter and the particular warm smell of a house that had been cooking all day.

Owen came and sat on the arm of the sofa near his father.

"So what do we do now?" Owen asked.

"What do you mean?"

"I mean — we just found out we have a cousin.

A forty-two-year-old cousin who's been in Grand Rapids for three weeks and didn't know whether to knock on the door." Owen glanced toward the kitchen.

"That's not a small thing."

"No," Richard said.

"It's not."

"So what do we do?"

Richard looked at the letter on the side table.

Then he looked at the kitchen doorway, where Graham had appeared again, holding a bowl of something, looking uncertain about where to put it.

"Elaine," Richard called.

"What?"

"Tell him where to put the potatoes."

A beat.

"On the table, Graham," Elaine's voice came back.

"Right side of the turkey.

And stop standing in the doorway."

Graham put the bowl on the table.

He looked at Richard.

Richard looked back.

Neither of them said anything.

But Graham pulled out the chair on the right side and sat down, and Richard nodded once, and that was enough for now.

Mara watched it.

Then Owen leaned toward her.

"So," he said quietly.

"You sat down with a stranger in a bakery on Christmas Eve."

"He looked lonely."

"He's our cousin."

"I didn't know that at the time."

Owen stared at her.

"How do you do that?"

"What?"

"Just.

Walk up to people."

Mara thought about it.

"He had cold coffee," she said.

"And no phone.

On Christmas Eve." She paused.

"That tells you everything."

Owen looked across at Graham, who was now listening to Claire explain the seating arrangements with the focused attention of someone determined to be helpful.

"Yeah," Owen said quietly.

"I guess it does."

Elaine appeared in the doorway with the turkey.

"Sit down," she said.

"All of you.

May you like

It's Christmas."

They sat.

Related Stories

Other posts