Spotlight

Chapter 3: What Happened to Carol

Danny's hand tightened on my arm.

"Robert.

Talk to me."

I couldn't take my eyes off the man standing at the top of the courthouse steps.

He was heavier than I remembered.

His hair had gone completely white.

He wore a pale blue suit and a smile that looked practiced — the kind of smile a man wears when he's spent years making people comfortable around him.

"His name is Gerald Hafton," I said.

Danny went quiet for a second.

"Should that mean something to me?"

"You never met him.

He came into my life after you and I lost touch." I pulled my helmet off slowly.

"He was my neighbor.

Back in Columbus.

1989."

Our other two friends, Marcus and Pete, had walked up beside us.

The four of us stood on the edge of the crowd, watching the wedding guests settle into their white chairs.

"What did he do?" Marcus asked.

I hadn't said the name Gerald Hafton out loud in over twenty years.

Saying it now felt like opening a door I'd spent a long time keeping shut.

"There was a woman on our street," I said.

"Carol Dempsey.

She lived alone with her daughter.

Single mother, worked double shifts at the hospital.

Quiet woman.

The kind of neighbor who always waved but never bothered anyone."

Pete crossed his arms.

"And Hafton?"

"Hafton moved in two doors down in the spring of '89.

Friendly.

Always offering to help people.

Fixing things, carrying groceries." I paused.

"Within six months, he had Carol convinced to let him manage her finances.

Said he had a background in investment.

Said he could help her save for her daughter's college."

Nobody said anything.

The wedding music started up — something soft and acoustic, played by a man with a guitar near the courthouse door.

"He took everything she had," I said.

"Her savings.

Her retirement account.

A small inheritance she'd gotten from her mother.

All of it, gone inside a year.

When Carol finally understood what had happened, she went to the police." I stopped.

"They investigated.

But Hafton had covered his tracks well.

The charges didn't stick.

He walked."

"And Carol?" Danny asked.

I watched Hafton lean over and say something to the groom.

The young man laughed nervously.

"She lost the house eight months later.

Moved away.

I tried to find her a few years after that and couldn't." I turned to look at Danny.

"Her daughter would have been about six years old when it all happened."

The four of us stood there in the warm Tennessee morning while the wedding guests fanned themselves with paper programs and the guitarist played something that sounded almost cheerful.

Then Danny said the thing I had already been thinking.

"Robert.

How old do you think that bride is?"

May you like

I looked toward the courthouse doors.

She hadn't come out yet.

Related Stories

Other posts