Spotlight

Chapter 8: The Recording

Grace listened to it twice.

She sat at her desk with Vanessa's phone between her hands and played it through both times without speaking.

Marcus Webb sat in the chair beside mine.

He had come within the hour, and when he'd seen Vanessa walk through Grace's office door his expression had gone through three separate things before settling on something that looked like grim recognition.

When the recording finished the second time, Grace set the phone down very carefully.

"He named Richard Hale," she said.

"Explicitly," I said.

"Richard is going to have a significant problem."

"That's between Richard and his bar license."

Marcus leaned forward.

"Is the recording admissible?"

"This is a one-party consent state," Grace said.

"Vanessa was a party to the conversation.

Yes." She looked at Vanessa.

"I need you to understand what you're doing.

If you provide this recording to support Emily's case, Daniel will come at you with everything he has."

"He's already coming at me with everything he has," Vanessa said.

"At least this way it means something."

Grace nodded once.

Then she picked up her phone and called Paul Sutter.

He answered on the second ring.

"Mr.

Sutter, this is Grace Alderman.

I represent Emily Carter.

I believe we spoke yesterday." A pause while he responded.

"Yes.

I'd like to revise my earlier position.

We're prepared to make Mrs.

Carter available for a brief conversation this afternoon, along with two additional sources and documentary evidence.

I think you'll find the story is considerably larger than what you've been given." Another pause.

"Three o'clock works.

Yes.

We'll come to you."

She ended the call and looked around the room.

"Three hours," she said.

"I need everything organized.

Marcus, I need your auditor's complete report and her contact information.

Vanessa, I need originals of both sets of documents and a written statement from you detailing the backdating request.

Emily—" she looked at me — "I need you to walk me through the original Hargrove Trust financing structure so I can explain it to Sutter in plain language.

He's a financial journalist.

He'll understand the documents, but he needs the human version first."

"And the recording?" Marcus asked.

"The recording goes to Sutter and to the district attorney's office.

Simultaneously." Grace stood.

"If Daniel is going to make Emily the story, we're going to make sure the real story runs first and runs loudest."

She was already pulling files.

For the next two and a half hours, Grace's office looked like a war room.

Documents spread across the conference table.

The auditor joined us by phone for forty minutes.

Vanessa's written statement took three drafts because Grace kept finding places where the language was soft and she needed it hard and specific.

At one point Marcus left to take a call in the hallway and came back looking tight around the eyes.

"Daniel called me," he said.

The room went quiet.

"He offered to reinstate my original equity position and pay me the difference between the forced buyout and fair market value." Marcus sat down.

"He wants me to withdraw my auditor's report and sign a statement saying I acted out of personal grievance."

Grace looked at him steadily.

"What did you say?"

"I told him I'd think about it." Marcus looked at me.

"So he'd stop thinking about us for the next two hours."

Grace allowed herself a very small smile.

At five minutes to three we walked into the Tribune's building.

Paul Sutter met us in a conference room on the fourth floor.

He was younger than I'd expected — mid-thirties, careful eyes, the kind of stillness that meant he was always listening for the thing behind the thing people said.

He looked at the size of our folder stack and his careful expression shifted slightly.

Grace set the recording phone in the center of the table.

"Before we begin," she said, "I'd like you to hear something."

She pressed play.

Daniel's voice filled the conference room.

*"If Emily files anything, we move the Hargrove documents into play.

Richard knows what to do.

The press gets the trust story, she spends six months defending herself, and by the time anyone looks at Bridgepoint it'll be buried under the noise."*

Sutter's pen stopped moving.

He looked at the phone.

Then he looked at me.

"Mrs.

Carter," he said.

"I think I've been working with an incomplete picture."

"Yes," I said.

"Let me show you the rest of it."

Three hours later, Grace and I walked out of the Tribune building into early evening light.

Marcus had left an hour before to meet with his attorney.

Vanessa had given her statement and gone home.

It was just the two of us on the sidewalk.

"He'll know by morning," I said.

"He'll know tonight," Grace said.

"Sutter is filing before midnight."

I looked up at the sky.

It was that particular shade of early evening blue that doesn't last long.

"Grace," I said.

"Is it over?"

"The legal part is just beginning," she said.

"But the part where he controls the story — yes.

That part is over."

My phone rang.

Daniel's number.

May you like

I let it go to voicemail.

For the first time in two days, that felt like the right decision for reasons that had nothing to do with strategy.

Related Stories

Other posts