Chapter 3: What Chloe Knew

I turned to face Nicolai fully for the first time.
He was sitting on the edge of the desk, his hands pressed flat against his knees.
Whatever he was about to say, he had been carrying it for longer than one morning.
"Tell me," I said.
"All of it."
He exhaled slowly.
"Chloe — my sister — she and Evelyn have been close for about four years.
But around eight months ago, something changed.
Evelyn started calling Chloe at odd hours.
Late nights, early mornings.
Chloe thought she was just lonely.
You travel a lot, she said.
She assumed it was that."
"But it wasn't that."
"No." Nicolai shook his head.
"About six weeks ago, Chloe found out what was actually happening.
Evelyn had confided in her.
She told Chloe she was planning to leave you, and that she needed someone she trusted to keep quiet while the arrangements were made."
"And Chloe agreed to that."
He didn't flinch from my tone.
"Chloe didn't know about the accounts.
She didn't know about your brother.
She thought it was just a marriage ending — a woman leaving quietly.
She felt for her."
"So why are you telling me now?"
Nicolai met my eyes.
"Because three days ago, Chloe saw the boxes going into that sedan.
And she saw the way Dennis spoke to Evelyn."
I went very still.
"What do you mean — the way he spoke to her?"
"He wasn't kind." Nicolai paused.
"Chloe said Evelyn looked frightened.
Not of you.
Of him."
The room felt smaller than it had a moment before.
"Chloe called me that night," Nicolai continued.
"She was scared.
She said she thought Evelyn had gotten into something she couldn't get out of.
She asked me to come stay here, close by, in case Evelyn needed someone.
That's the real reason I'm in this house, Arthur.
Not the plumbing.
Evelyn asked Chloe to keep someone nearby."
"She was using you as protection," I said slowly.
"From Dennis."
Nicolai nodded once.
My mind was running backward through eleven years at speed.
Dennis helping us draft our wills.
Dennis recommending the investment firm we used.
Dennis sitting across from me at my own dining room table, asking careful questions about our portfolio with that slight, attentive smile.
I had called it thoroughness.
I had called it brotherly care.
"Did Chloe say anything else?"
"She said Evelyn tried to pull back two weeks ago.
That she told Dennis she had changed her mind about leaving.
That she wanted to work things out with you."
"And Dennis?"
Nicolai's jaw tightened.
"He told her it was too late.
That the paperwork was already in motion and her name was already attached to accounts she couldn't explain."
I stood up from the floor where I had been sitting without realizing it.
My hand found the edge of the filing cabinet.
The metal was cold.
"He trapped her," I said.
"That's what Chloe believes."
I looked at the single sheet of paper still lying on the empty desk.
The handwritten account breakdown.
The six-figure number at the bottom with a secondary account I didn't recognize.
And below it, in a different pen — slightly different handwriting than the rest — a phone number with no name beside it.
I hadn't noticed that detail before.
I took a photograph of the page with my phone.
"Where is Chloe right now?" I asked.
"She's been trying to reach Evelyn since yesterday morning.
No answer."
My phone buzzed in my hand.
An unknown number.
Chicago area code.
I answered it.
"Mr.
Vance." The voice was a woman's.
Steady, professional.
"My name is Renata Solis.
I'm an attorney.
I believe we need to speak today.
It concerns your wife, your brother, and approximately $340,000 in funds that were moved without your authorization over the past eleven years."
The line hummed quietly between us.
"How do you know about that?" I asked.
May you like
"Because your wife called me four days ago," she said.
"And she is the one who gave me your number."