Chapter 7: What Carol Found

Carol Nguyen sent her preliminary report on a Wednesday evening.
Arthur forwarded it to me with a single line: *Call me when you've read it.*
I read it twice before I called him.
"The pattern is consistent," Arthur said when he picked up.
"Eighteen months of data.
Thirty-one instances where bid information, contract terms, or client pricing was passed from a device registered to the home address to an external contact.
That contact traces back to Gerald Marsh's firm."
"Thirty-one times."
"Thirty-one confirmed.
Carol believes there may be more that were deleted before she could reconstruct them, but what she has is enough."
I sat at my kitchen table with the report on the screen in front of me.
Thirty-one times.
Sunday dinners.
Business calls my father took at home.
Documents he reviewed in the evening while Renata refilled his glass of wine and asked how his day had gone.
"What's the next step?" I asked.
"I've spoken with a colleague — David Park.
He handles commercial litigation and he's worked with the district attorney's office before on cases involving corporate espionage.
He believes the evidence meets the threshold for a civil suit against both Renata and Marsh.
Potentially more."
"Crjminal charges?"
"That's for the DA's office to determine.
David is going to make a referral Monday morning.
Carol's report goes with it."
I was quiet.
"Emma.
Your father needs to know before this moves officially.
Once David files, it becomes a matter of record.
Your father cannot find out from a document or a phone call from a stranger."
"I know." I had known this was coming.
I had been building toward it and dreading it at the same time.
"Do you want me there when you tell him?"
I thought about my father's face at the dinner table.
The way he had turned his coffee cup in both hands.
"Yes," I said.
"Please."
We met at my father's office on Saturday morning.
I had told him I wanted to show him something related to the business irregularities he had mentioned.
He had said, *Finally, someone taking it seriously,* and something about that — his relief, his openness, his complete trust — almost made me call the whole thing off.
But I thought about thirty-one times.
And I went.
Arthur arrived first.
My father shook his hand warmly, called him Art, offered coffee.
Then I set the folder on his desk and sat down.
My father looked at the folder.
Then at me.
Then at Arthur.
"What is this?" he asked.
"Dad," I said.
"I need you to listen to all of it before you say anything.
Can you do that?"
He sat down slowly.
"You're scaring me, Emma."
"I know.
I'm sorry."
I told him.
Arthur filled in the legal and financial detail where I needed him.
My father sat without moving for the first several minutes.
Then he picked up one of the pages.
Set it down.
Picked up another.
At one point he said, very quietly, "Gerald."
Not Renata.
Gerald.
I waited.
Then he turned to the page with the timestamps.
He found the date of my graduation.
He found the 11:47 entry.
He stared at it for a long time.
"She was—" he started.
"Yes," I said.
He put the page down.
He pressed both hands flat on his desk.
His face had gone very still in a way I had never seen before — not angry, not crying, just profoundly, completely still, like something inside him was reorganizing itself around a new and terrible fact.
"She was with you backstage," he said.
"Yes."
"She told me you understood.
That you had said it was fine."
"She told you whatever kept you from calling me that morning."
The office was very quiet.
My father looked at Arthur.
"How strong is it?" he asked.
His voice was level.
Professional.
He was a businessman, and even now, even here, he was going to deal with this like one.
"Strong," Arthur said.
"Carol's report is solid.
David Park is filing Monday."
My father nodded.
Slowly, once.
Then he looked at me, and his face broke — just for a moment, just one second — before he pulled it back together.
"I'm sorry," he said.
"Emma, I am so sorry."
"Dad—"
"I should have seen it."
"She was careful.
She was very careful."
"She was in our home."
"I know."
He stood up.
Walked to the window.
Stood with his back to us for a long moment.
"Where is she now?" he asked.
"Home," I said.
"She doesn't know."
He nodded again.
His shoulders rose once, then settled.
May you like
"All right," he said.
"Tell me what I need to do."