Spotlight

Chapter 9: What My Father Said When He Saw the Photographs

We stayed at the university for another hour.

My father took photographs with people he knew.

I stood beside him and smiled and shook hands.

I had the envelope in my bag the whole time.

I said nothing.

On the drive home, he sat in the back again.

Darcy drove.

I watched the road.

When we pulled into the driveway, he rested his hand briefly on my shoulder before he got out.

"Thank you for letting me be here today," he said.

I didn't answer that.

I couldn't yet.

Inside, Linda was in the kitchen.

Mia was not visible.

The house was clean and quiet in the way a house gets when someone has spent time restoring its surface because they couldn't fix anything underneath.

My father sat at the kitchen table.

Linda put coffee in front of him without being asked.

Darcy touched my arm at the door.

"Call me," she said quietly.

"I will."

When she left, I sat down across from my father.

"There's something you need to see," I said.

I put the envelope on the table.

He looked at it.

"Where did this come from?"

"A woman named Ruth Calloway.

She said she knows Gerald Fitch.

And she said what's inside should go to your attorney."

My father picked it up.

He opened it slowly.

He looked at the photographs for a long time without speaking.

Linda had stopped moving in the kitchen.

"That's Gerald," my father said finally.

He turned one photograph slightly toward the light.

"Yes."

"And that's—" He stopped.

Something in his face shifted.

"That's Dennis Hale.

From Prescott Accounting."

"Yes."

He set the photograph down on the table.

"Dennis told me those numbers came from my own reports," he said.

"He sat in my office and told me there was a discrepancy and that it had been flagged.

He made it sound like he was doing me a courtesy.

Coming to me first."

"He was sitting with Fitch eleven months ago," I said.

"A month before any of that."

My father was quiet for a moment.

"He was already working with Fitch."

"It looks that way."

Linda pulled out a chair and sat down.

My father looked at the photograph again.

Then he looked at me.

"How did she know to find you?"

"She's Robert Calloway's aunt.

She said she'd known about Fitch for a long time and had been waiting for a moment where giving this to someone would actually matter."

"And she decided today was that moment."

"She said she was sorry it was my graduation day."

My father made a sound.

It wasn't quite a laugh.

"Of course she did." He put the photographs back in the envelope and held it with both hands.

"Do you know what Fitch told me six months ago, when I asked him directly what his complaint was about?" He looked up.

"He told me he was protecting his investment.

He said he owed it to himself to make sure the records were accurate." He shook his head slowly.

"He said it with a straight face.

He shook my hand afterward."

"He built the story before he told it to you," I said.

"Yes." My father set the envelope flat on the table and put his hand on top of it.

"He did."

Linda spoke for the first time.

"Thomas.

What does this mean?

For the case?"

"It means I need to call Calloway tonight." He looked at her.

"And it means what Fitch filed is going to look very different to a judge once his own accountant's presence at that meeting is established."

"Will it be enough?"

"I don't know yet." He paused.

"But it changes what we're walking into."

He picked up his phone.

He looked at me once before he dialed.

"You went to your graduation today," he said.

"You got your diploma.

You took photographs."

"Yes."

"And then you came home with evidence that changes a fourteen-month legal dispute."

"Someone handed it to me."

"You still had to decide what to do with it." He held my gaze for one moment.

"Your mother was right about you.

She was completely right."

He pressed call and stood and walked toward the hall.

I sat at the kitchen table.

Linda wrapped both hands around her coffee cup.

From the hall came the low sound of my father's voice, controlled and careful, explaining to Robert Calloway what had been placed in an envelope at a fountain on the afternoon of his daughter's graduation.

Linda looked at me across the table.

"He loved her very much," she said.

"Your mother."

"I know."

"I think—" She stopped.

Looked at the coffee.

"I think I made it harder for him to show you that.

By being here the way I was." She didn't dress it up.

"I'm not asking for anything from you.

I just want to say it plainly, because I think I owe you that much at least."

The hall went quiet for a moment.

Then my father's voice again, more animated.

Something had landed.

"Does Mia know?" I asked.

"Know what?"

"Any of it.

The photographs.

Ruth Calloway."

"No."

"Tell her," I said.

"When the time is right.

Tell her that the reason our family is still in this house — if we are — might partly be because of a woman who sat in a restaurant eleven months ago and decided to wait." I looked at Linda.

"People who do the right thing quietly deserve to be known."

Linda looked at me for a moment.

Then she nodded.

My father came back into the kitchen.

"Calloway wants the originals of those photographs by morning," he said.

"He says if what Ruth told you is accurate, and if Dennis Hale's involvement can be established, Fitch's filing is built on a foundation that doesn't hold."

He sat down.

He looked tired.

But it was a different kind of tired now.

The kind that comes after something has been decided rather than before.

"What happens to Fitch?" I asked.

"That's for Calloway and the court to work out." He picked up his coffee.

"But a man who fabricated evidence and recruited someone else to deliver it is not standing on solid ground."

"And Dennis Hale?"

My father looked at the envelope.

"Also not standing on solid ground."

He drank his coffee.

Outside, the evening had gone soft and orange.

A neighbor's dog was barking at something.

A car moved slowly down the street.

May you like

It was almost a normal evening.

Almost.

Related Stories

Other posts