Chapter 4: What My Father Buried

I did not go to the hospital that morning.
I called Emily and told her the car was having trouble and that I would be there by noon.
She was tired and happy and too full of new-baby wonder to question it.
I hated lying to her.
I did it anyway.
When I hung up, my mother was already at the counter making tea she would not drink.
"How much did Dad pay her?" I said.
She set the kettle down carefully.
"Enough."
"That's not an answer."
"Forty thousand dollars." She turned around.
"In 1989.
Which was a great deal of money then."
"And in exchange she gave up all rights to Catherine."
"Yes."
"And agreed never to contact us again."
"Yes."
"But she kept making the blankets." I said it half to myself.
The silver stars.
Two of them.
One for each twin.
She had known.
She had been keeping track for decades, quietly, from wherever she had disappeared to.
"She kept watching."
"I don't know how she found out about Emily's pregnancy," my mother said.
"I don't know how she knew about the twins before they were even born.
That card said *as promised*.
She made that promise in 1989 and she has apparently been keeping it for thirty-four years."
I sat with that for a moment.
"Do you think she's dangerous?"
My mother brought the tea to the table and sat down.
She wrapped both hands around the mug without drinking.
"No," she said finally.
"I think she's lonely.
And I think she's been carrying a loss for thirty-four years that nobody ever acknowledged." She looked up.
"Catherine d*ed, and Rosalind had no right to grieve her publicly.
No right to attend the funeral.
No right to tell anyone who she was." Her voice dropped.
"I never thought about what that cost her.
I should have."
That stopped me.
My mother — who had spent thirty-four years protecting the secret — was sitting across from me with something that looked very much like guilt.
"Mom.
This wasn't your fault."
"Wasn't it?" She set the mug down.
"Your father made the deal, yes.
But I knew.
I knew the whole time and I chose our comfort over her truth.
Over Catherine's truth." She pressed her fingers against the edge of the blanket closest to her.
"These blankets aren't a threat.
They're a message from a woman who lost everything and just wants to know the children her grandchild left behind."
My phone buzzed again.
I looked at it.
Not Rosalind this time.
Emily.
*Mom, everything okay?
You seem far away today.*
I looked at my mother across the table.
At the black blankets with their quiet silver stars.
At thirty-four years of a secret that had been folded just as neatly, just as deliberately, and stored in a place where no one was supposed to look.
"I have to tell her," I said.
My mother's head came up sharply.
"Not yet."
"She has a right—"
"Not today." Her voice was firm, but not cruel.
"She just gave birth.
She is exhausted and she is happy and she has two daughters who need her whole heart right now.
Give her one week.
Please.
One week."
I looked at Emily's message on the screen.
"And Rosalind?"
"I'll call her," my mother said quietly.
"I'll call her myself."
That surprised me more than anything else that morning.
"You have her number?"
My mother's expression shifted — just slightly.
Something moved behind her eyes that I could not quite read.
"I've always had her number," she said.
I stared at her.
May you like
She looked back at me steadily.
And the quiet in the kitchen took on a completely different weight.