Chapter 4: The Doctor Who Knew Too Much

Elena entered the study and closed the door behind her.
“You dismissed this woman three days ago,” she said.
“Why is she back?”
Santiago placed the recorder on the desk.
“You will call her Ruby.”
Elena’s smile tightened.
“Whatever name she uses, she is unstable.”
Ruby stepped forward.
“Tell him about Sophia’s first assessment.”
“I don’t discuss patients with disgraced former clinicians.”
“You wrote that she showed no meaningful comprehension.”
“That was my medical judgment.”
Ruby pointed toward Sophia.
“Ask her whether green or blue is her favorite color.”
“This is absurd.”
“Ask her.”
Elena looked at Sophia for one second too long.
Her right hand moved near her hip—two quick signs.
Stop this.
Santiago rose slowly.
“You know sign language.”
Elena lowered her hand.
“Any competent specialist knows basic signs.”
“Then why did you never use them with Sophia?”
“She was unresponsive.”
Sophia seized the writing board.
LIAR.
Elena opened her medical case.
“This is exactly what I feared.
Ruby has created dependence and hostility.”
“You created seven years of isolation,” Ruby said.
“I protected a traumatized child.”
“You billed Santiago for conversations you claimed Sophia could not understand.”
Elena faced her daughter.
“You stole confidential records and entered this home under false pretenses.
Shall we discuss who broke the law?”
Ruby’s face lost color, but she did not step back.
“Show him the intake recording.”
“There is no recording.”
“There was.
Room 412.
November seventeenth.”
Elena snapped the case shut.
“Your memory has always been dramatic.”
Santiago pressed the button on Ruby’s recorder.
Elena’s voice filled the room.
“If you challenge me again, no board in this state will let you near a patient.
And if you contact the Morettis, Sophia will be transferred somewhere even you cannot find her.”
The recording ended.
Elena stared at Ruby.
“You recorded your own mother?”
“I learned from you to keep proof.”
Santiago moved between Elena and the door.
“You threatened my sister.”
“I warned a disturbed woman against interfering with treatment.”
“You will give me every file.”
“No.”
“That was not a request.”
Elena pulled out her phone.
“Then this conversation is over.”
“Put it down,” Santiago said.
“I have already contacted Judge Mercer.
Sophia’s emergency guardianship order names me as supervising physician if her condition is compromised.”
Santiago’s expression hardened.
“I am her legal guardian.”
“And you allowed an unlicensed stranger to manipulate her.
That may change by morning.”
Sophia grabbed Santiago’s sleeve.
Elena looked at her.
“Come with me, sweetheart.
You’re overwhelmed.”
Sophia backed away.
“Don’t speak to her as if she is five,” Ruby said.
“I am the only person here qualified to judge her condition.”
Mrs.
Delaney knocked once and entered.
“There are two county officers at the gate.”
Elena’s smile returned.
“They’re here to enforce the evaluation order.”
“You arranged this before you came,” Santiago said.
“I anticipated your temper.”
Ruby reached for Sophia, but Elena lifted one finger.
“Touch her, and I will report a violation of your suspension.”
Sophia clung to Santiago’s arm.
He looked down at her trembling hands.
“I won’t let them take you.”
Tomas entered with a document.
“You may not have a choice tonight.
The order is signed.”
Elena held out her hand to Sophia.
“Be sensible,” she said.
“You remember what happens when people refuse to cooperate.”
Sophia froze.
May you like
Then her shaking finger traced two words against Santiago’s palm.
Red notebook.