Chapter 6: The Other Option

Gloria left the house at eleven.
I watched her from the upstairs window.
She backed her silver car out of the driveway with the particular precision of a woman who does not rush and does not explain herself.
She didn't look up at the house.
Derek stayed in the guest room with the door closed.
I could hear him on the phone, his voice low and steady with occasional silences that meant someone else was doing the talking.
Ava slept.
I ate toast standing at the kitchen counter.
I unlocked my father's study with the small brass key he had kept taped inside a copy of *To Kill a Mockingbird* on the third shelf — "because no one steals what they think they've already read," he used to say — and I opened the lockbox.
Inside: the original deed.
The restriction clause.
His will.
A letter addressed to me in his handwriting, sealed, dated six months before he died.
I had not opened it before.
I sat down in his chair and opened it now.
*Naomi,*
*If you're reading this before you need to, put it away and come back when you do.*
*If you're reading this because something has gone wrong, then I want you to know I thought about this.
I thought about all the ways people might try to take what I built for you.
I added the restriction clause because your grandfather lost everything to a signature he didn't understand, and I swore that wouldn't happen to you.*
*There is one more thing I did not tell you.*
*The deed has a secondary condition.
It is recorded with the county and also with a separate attorney — not a family friend, not anyone connected to your life in Charleston.
His name is Warren Calloway.*
His name is Warren Calloway.
I read the line twice.
Mr.
Calloway.
The silver-haired man with the briefcase who had driven to this house at dusk and handed me back my front door.
My father had known him.
My father had chosen him.
My father had placed a second layer of protection into this house twenty years ago and never told me, because he said the best protection is the kind the wrong people don't know to look for.
I set the letter down on the desk.
My phone rang.
It was Renata.
"I've been in contact with Calloway's office," she said.
"He's already filed a formal objection with the title company.
The sale is suspended indefinitely." A pause.
"He also told me your father had a standing instruction in place.
If anything triggered the restriction clause, Calloway was to be notified automatically.
The title search triggered it."
"My father set that up," I said.
"Years ago." Another pause.
"Naomi, Derek's attorney called my office twenty minutes ago."
"What did he say?"
"He said his client is prepared to acknowledge that the document process had irregularities, and that he wants to discuss a resolution."
"What kind of resolution?"
"He used the phrase 'equitable partition.' Which means he wants to split the value of the house in exchange for dropping any further legal action against Derek."
My hand tightened around the phone.
"He wants half."
"Yes."
"Of a house my father built and left entirely to me."
"Yes."
I looked at the letter on the desk.
At my father's handwriting.
Neat and slanted and completely certain of itself even on the last line.
"Tell him no," I said.
"I already did," Renata said.
"I told him the position of my client is that no fraud-derived agreement has any standing, and that we will be filing with the county recorder's office and the state bar this afternoon."
A beat of silence.
"The state bar?" I said.
"Gareth Sloane has been a licensed attorney in South Carolina for twenty-two years," she said.
"If he notarized a fraudulent document, that license is at risk." Another pause.
"Derek's attorney went very quiet when I mentioned that."
"I imagine he did."
"There's something else.
My paralegal ran the deed history this morning.
Conrad Hale's development group has three other properties in Charleston county that passed through Gareth Sloane's office in the last four years."
I set the letter down on the desk.
"He's done this before," I said.
"That is what the pattern suggests," Renata said.
"I've already sent a note to the DA's office."
After we hung up, I sat in the study for a long time.
My father's books around me.
His handwriting on the desk in front of me.
His brass lamp.
His old wooden letter opener shaped like a fish that he had brought back from a trip to Nova Scotia when I was eleven and that I had always thought was ugly and had never once thought about throwing away.
Footsteps on the stairs.
Derek appeared in the doorway of the study.
He looked at the letter.
At the lockbox.
At my face.
"I need to talk to you," he said.
"I know," I said.
He came in and sat down across from me, in the chair where I used to sit as a child while my father read, and he looked at me with an expression I had not seen from him in years.
Not calculation.
Not comfort.
Something that might, in a different life, have been shame.
"I didn't forge your signature," he said.
"Then whose signature is on the document?" I said.
He was quiet for a long moment.
"Gloria's handwriting looks like yours," he said.
"She's always said that."
The room went very still.
"Derek," I said slowly.
"Are you telling me your mother signed my name?"
He didn't look away.
May you like
But he didn't answer either.
And that was answer enough.