Chapter 5: The Voice Behind the Closed Door

Judge Shaw cleared the courtroom of everyone except counsel, the child advocate, and us.
Ariana waited with Lorraine in another room.
Nora placed the laptop near the bench.
“The recording is twenty-three minutes long.
I suggest we begin at minute fourteen.”
Martin stood.
“We object.
We don’t know when or how this was created.”
“The file contains a date and location,” Nora said.
“Mrs.
Grant may challenge it after we hear enough to identify the voices.”
Judge Shaw nodded.
“Play it.”
Ariana’s recorded voice came first.
“I’m doing my feelings journal because Mrs.
Miller said talking can make your stomach stop hurting.”
A door opened in the recording.
Sarah’s voice followed.
“Who are you talking to?”
“My tablet.”
“Turn it off.”
“But it’s homework.”
“Did you tell your father you wanted to live there?”
“No.”
“Did he ask you?”
“No.”
“Then why did he call your teacher?”
“I wrote about his kitchen.”
The recording went quiet except for a child breathing too quickly.
Sarah spoke again.
“Do you understand what happens if you tell people you prefer him?
A judge could take you away, and I would be alone because of you.”
In the courtroom, Sarah covered her mouth.
I stood so quickly Helen caught my sleeve.
“You put that on her?”
“I was frightened,” Sarah said.
“I didn’t mean it that way.”
The recording continued.
“I don’t want you alone,” Ariana said.
“Then stop writing things that make me look like a bad mother.”
Nora paused the file.
Judge Shaw’s voice was low.
“Mrs.
Grant, did you delete this recording today?”
“I deleted junk from a child’s tablet.”
“You knew what was on it.”
Sarah turned to me.
“Tell them I’m a good mother.”
I looked at the woman who had remembered every school form, every dentist appointment, every library day.
“You did good things,” I said.
“But you made Ariana responsible for your pain.”
“And you left me responsible for everything else!”
“I did.
I was selfish and unreliable.”
“Then withdraw your petition.”
“No.”
Sarah leaned over the table.
“I will agree to equal time.
No investigation, no public findings.
We tell Ariana this was a misunderstanding.”
Helen stepped forward.
“Are you proposing a deal in exchange for concealing altered evidence?”
“I’m trying to save my daughter from a public fight.”
“You’re trying to save yourself,” Lorraine said from the doorway.
Sarah spun around.
“You were told to wait outside.”
“Ariana asked for her rabbit.
I came to get Daniel’s key.”
Lorraine held out her hand to me.
Her fingers were shaking.
Sarah pointed toward the hall.
“If he takes Ariana, I’ll accept the nursing position in Oregon.
My sister already offered us a room.”
“You cannot remove Ariana from the state,” Helen said.
“I’m still her primary parent.”
Judge Shaw’s pen stopped moving.
“Not if this court finds you intend to interfere with contact.”
Sarah stared at the judge.
“So I’m being punished for having a job opportunity?”
“You just described taking a child across state lines because her father refused your deal.”
Martin whispered, “Stop talking.”
Nora restarted the recording.
Near the end, Sarah’s voice softened.
“Give me the worksheet, Ariana.”
“No.”
“If you love me, you’ll let me fix it.”
There was the sound of paper tearing, followed by Ariana’s cry.
Nora stopped the file.
“The rest concerns matters unrelated to today.”
A technician entered and handed her a printed report.
Nora scanned the first page, then looked at Sarah.
“What?” Sarah demanded.
“The deleted file was not the only material recovered.”
Martin closed his briefcase.
“We need to speak privately.”
Nora placed the report before Judge Shaw.
“Someone also used Ariana’s tablet to send cancellation messages from Daniel’s account,” she said.
May you like
“The login history leads to Mrs.
Grant’s home.”