Chapter 5: The Woman from the Lake

Elena worked from a laptop in Robert’s vehicle while wedding guests crowded outside the dark chapel.
“They erased the local archive,” she said.
“The off-site copy is intact, but we need the original access logs to establish custody.”
“Who had administrator access?” I asked.
“Robert, me, and the former owner of Sentinel.”
Robert looked at the screen.
“Peter’s father owned Sentinel before Katherine’s company purchased it.”
A woman in a gray housekeeper’s uniform approached the vehicle.
She was clutching a thick envelope.
“My name is Eleanor Shaw,” she said.
“I’ve worked for Margaret for nineteen years.”
Robert blocked the door.
“Why are you here?”
“Because I heard the recording in the chapel, and I know they did this before.”
Eleanor placed the envelope in my hands.
Inside was a photograph of Andrew beside a dark-haired woman at the Lowell family lake house.
“Who is she?”
“Laura Bennett.
Andrew was engaged to her six years ago.”
Andrew had told me he had never been engaged.
“What happened to Laura?”
“Their boat failed on the lake.
Margaret told everyone Laura had left the country afterward.”
Eleanor took out a folded hospital bill.
“She survived.
I drove her to a private clinic because Margaret refused to call an ambulance.”
“Why didn’t you report it?”
“Margaret said she would have my grandson charged for taking money from her desk.
He was seventeen, and she knew he hadn’t done it.”
Her hands shook, but she pushed a small brass key toward Robert.
“This opens Peter’s cabinet in the old Sentinel office.
I saw him place insurance forms inside last week.”
“You could lose your job,” I said.
Eleanor met my eyes.
“I watched you walk toward that altar, and I saw Laura all over again.
I will not stay silent twice.”
Robert arranged for Eleanor to be taken somewhere safe.
Then Elena located Laura Bennett at a rehabilitation center two hours away.
Laura agreed to meet us in a private office.
She walked with a cane and stopped when she saw the photograph.
“He kept that?”
“Laura, I need you to tell me what happened on the lake.”
“Andrew loosened the fuel line.
When the boat stopped, he told me to get into the water.”
My throat tightened.
“Why would you obey him?”
“He said the boat was sinking.
Then he pushed away from me and watched.”
Robert pulled out a chair, but I remained standing.
“Did he admit it?”
“Not then.
At the clinic, Margaret offered me five hundred thousand dollars to say it was an accjdent.”
“Did you take it?”
Laura’s eyes filled.
“Yes.
My mother needed surgery, and Margaret promised Andrew would never do it again.”
I gripped the back of the chair until my fingers hurt.
“He spent three years telling me I was safe with him.”
Laura reached for my wrist.
“Katherine, look at me.
You are not foolish because you believed someone who practiced lying.”
That kindness broke through the control I had held since the previous night.
I sat down, and tears fell before I could turn away.
Robert knelt beside the chair.
“You do not have to carry this like a prosecutor.”
“I was going to marry him.”
“But you didn’t,” Laura said.
“You heard the truth, and you stopped.”
I wiped my face.
“Will you testify?”
Laura drew a long breath.
“Yes.
This time my mother isn’t here for Margaret to use against me.”
Robert’s phone rang.
He answered, listened, and put the call on speaker.
Peter’s voice came through.
“I have the original server and the insurance forms.”
“Where are you?” I asked.
“At the Lowell lake house.”
“Why should I trust you?”
“Because Andrew just told me I’m taking the blame for everything.”
A door slammed on Peter’s end.
His breath quickened.
May you like
“He’s here,” Peter whispered.
“And he brought Margaret.”