Chapter 4: The Signature That Should Not Exist

Denise Brooks reached the school office twenty minutes later.
Malik stood when his mother entered, but he could not make himself meet her eyes.
“Come here,” Denise said.
“I didn’t do anything wrong.”
“I know.” She pulled him against her.
“You never have to earn the right to be believed by me.”
Dr.
Carter placed the damaged folder on the conference table.
Sophie sat beside Malik while Grant Mercer and Ms.
Vale faced them from the other side.
Superintendent Pike entered carrying a second file.
“This has gone far enough,” he said.
“Mr.
Mercer has provided evidence that Malik withdrew from the competition yesterday.”
Malik stared at him.
“No, I didn’t.”
Pike pushed a form across the table.
“That is your signature.”
Denise picked it up.
“It looks like his name, but he didn’t write this.”
Ms.
Vale leaned forward.
“He signed it in my classroom.”
“You said he took the folder by mistake,” Dr.
Carter replied.
“Now you say he withdrew.
Which story should we believe?”
“The truthful one,” Ms.
Vale said.
“He became angry after learning his project had been disqualified.”
“For what?” Malik demanded.
Mercer answered before she could.
“Plagiarism.”
Malik’s face crumpled.
“You’re calling me a cheater?”
“The district should suspend judgment until the review is complete,” Pike said.
“Malik will surrender the award and remain home.”
Denise pushed back her chair.
“You’re punishing my son while the adults who cornered him stay here?”
Pike lowered his voice.
“Mrs.
Brooks, cooperation may protect Malik’s permanent record.”
Malik turned to his mother.
“Maybe I should give it back.”
Sophie grabbed his sleeve.
“No.
You showed me every version of that project.”
“They can write anything they want about me,” Malik whispered.
“Who’s going to believe us?”
The door opened behind them.
“I will,” a boy said.
Owen Mercer stood there holding a silver flash drive.
Grant rose so quickly that his chair struck the wall.
“Get outside, Owen.”
“No.”
“You don’t understand what you’re doing.”
“I understand that Malik won.” Owen placed the drive in front of Dr.
Carter.
“Dad made me submit Malik’s early design under my name.”
Mercer reached across the table, but Officer Cole blocked his arm.
“Don’t touch it,” Cole warned.
Owen’s voice shook.
“I told him I didn’t want the award.
He said our family doesn’t lose to people like Malik.”
Denise looked at Mercer.
“People like my son?”
Mercer’s jaw tightened.
“My child is confused and upset.”
“I’m not confused,” Owen said.
“Ms.
Vale gave Dad copies of Malik’s drafts.
The original files are on that drive.”
Ms.
Vale pointed at him.
“That is a terrible lie.”
Owen took a folded envelope from his pocket.
“Then why did you leave this in Dad’s car?”
Inside was a copy of the score sheet.
Malik’s score had been crossed out, and Owen’s had been written above it.
Dr.
Carter looked at Pike.
“Are you still sending Malik home?”
Pike glanced at Mercer.
“Until the files are verified, yes.”
“You saw the message,” Sophie said.
“You heard Owen.”
Pike closed the file.
“Mr.
Mercer sits on the district foundation board.
We will follow procedure.”
Denise’s hand trembled against the table.
“Procedure is what people hide behind when doing the right thing might cost them something.”
Mercer turned to her.
“Take your son home, Mrs.
Brooks.
If this becomes public, colleges will search his name and find an investigation into cheating.”
Malik’s shoulders dropped.
Owen stepped beside him.
“Then they’ll find my name too.
I’ll tell everyone who really cheated.”
Dr.
Carter inserted the flash drive into her laptop.
Four folders appeared, each dated weeks before the competition.
May you like
Then a fifth folder opened by itself.
It was labeled: PAYMENTS—VALE, PIKE, MERCER.