Chapter 4: The Anniversary Toast

I called Grace as soon as Eleanor left.
“She threatened to take Hailey.”
“Write down every word,” Grace said.
“And forward me the recording.”
“Should I cancel the dinner?”
“No.
Let Liam believe you know nothing.
We need time to trace those documents.”
For six days, I smiled when Liam entered the room.
I kissed his cheek, asked about work, and watched him guard his phone like it held his future.
On the anniversary evening, both families gathered around our dining table.
Beth sat beside Eleanor, wearing the silver bracelet I had given her for helping after Hailey’s birth.
“You look tired,” Beth said.
“So do you.”
Her fingers closed over the bracelet.
“New mothers need rest.”
“So do women carrying secrets.”
“Excuse me?”
Liam placed a hand on my chair.
“Claire’s emotional tonight.”
My father, Martin, looked up.
“She sounds perfectly clear to me.”
Dessert arrived.
Liam tapped his glass.
“To my beautiful wife,” he said.
“Two wonderful years, and many more ahead.”
Eleanor smiled first.
Beth did not look at me.
I stood and lifted my glass.
“To honesty,” I said.
“Especially between people who claim to love each other.”
Liam’s smile stiffened.
“Claire, sit down.”
“Not yet.”
I placed my phone beside the flowers and pressed play.
“She’s driving me insane,” Liam’s recorded voice said.
No one moved.
Then Beth’s voice came through the speaker.
“So when are you finally leaving Claire?”
My mother covered her mouth.
Martin’s chair scraped backward.
Liam lunged for the phone, but I picked it up.
“Give me that,” he said.
“Tell them it isn’t your voice.”
“You recorded me without permission.”
“Tell them, Liam.”
Beth stood.
“He told me the marriage was already over.”
“You held my daughter while you were planning to take her home.”
“I never wanted to hurt Hailey.”
“You wanted her house.”
Liam pointed at me.
“Look at her.
This is what I’ve been living with—suspicion, mood swings, secret recordings.”
Martin stepped between us.
“Don’t speak about my daughter that way.”
“You don’t know what happens here,” Liam said.
“Claire forgets things.
She cries constantly.
She can barely manage the baby.”
“I manage her every day while you visit Beth.”
Eleanor rose.
“This spectacle proves Liam’s concerns.”
“What concerns?” my mother asked.
Liam pulled a folder from his briefcase.
“These.”
He spread medical notes, printed messages, and a signed property transfer across the table.
“I’ve documented Claire’s instability for weeks,” he said.
“And she already signed the house agreement.”
“I did not.”
“Your signature is there.”
Grace had warned me this could happen, but seeing my name on the page still made my stomach turn.
Beth whispered, “Liam, you said she agreed.”
“Be quiet,” he told her.
The doorbell rang.
Megan, Liam’s sister, opened the door and looked into the room.
“There are two people outside,” she said.
“One is from family services.”
May you like
Liam met my eyes and smiled.
“I told you to behave sensibly.”