Chapter 4: The Story Serena Prepared

“I took him to a clinic,” Lily said.
Serena folded her arms.
“Without either parent’s permission.”
“Why?” I asked.
Lily looked at Ethan as the paramedics lifted him onto the stretcher.
“He had bruises on his back.
I needed someone to see them.”
The officer raised his notebook.
“Which clinic?”
“Rosewood Urgent Care.”
Serena stepped closer.
“She used a false name.”
“You told me you’d have me arrested if I used Ethan’s,” Lily said.
“That’s convenient.”
I walked beside the stretcher toward the door.
“We’re discussing this at the hospital.”
Serena reached for Ethan’s blanket.
The paramedic stopped her hand.
“Only one adult can ride with him.”
“I’m his mother.”
“I’m going,” I said.
Serena stared at me.
“If you leave me here with the police, you’re choosing her.”
“I’m choosing Ethan.”
The ambulance doors closed on Serena’s face.
At the hospital, a nurse carried Ethan through double doors while I answered questions at the desk.
Lily sat three chairs away, clutching the damaged phone.
“You should have told me,” I said.
“I tried.”
“When?”
“Three weeks ago.
Serena answered your phone.”
I pulled out my mobile and opened the call history.
There was no call from Lily.
“She deleted it,” Lily said.
“Then she told me you said I was becoming a problem.”
I sat beside her.
“I never said that.”
“I know that now.”
A doctor appeared in blue scrubs.
“Mr.
Hale?”
I stood so fast the chair scraped backward.
“Is Ethan all right?”
“His arm is fractured, but circulation is good.
We can treat it without surgery.”
My knees weakened.
Lily caught my elbow before I reached the wall.
The doctor lowered his voice.
“The injury does not match a simple fall from a changing table.”
“What does it match?”
“A forceful twist or pull.
I’ve also found older bruising in different stages of healing.”
I stared through the doors behind him.
“How long?”
“Some marks may be several weeks old.”
Lily began to cry.
“I should have taken him away sooner.”
The doctor turned to her.
“You brought him for care yesterday.
That matters.”
“No, it doesn’t,” she said.
“I took him back.”
“You took him back because Serena threatened your mother,” I said.
Lily looked at me.
“I took him back because I was scared.”
The truth in her voice struck harder than an excuse would have.
The doctor touched my shoulder.
“Your son needs you steady right now.”
“What kind of father misses this?”
“The kind someone worked very hard to deceive,” Lily said.
A woman’s heels clicked across the waiting room.
Serena entered with a gray-haired man carrying a leather case.
“This is my attorney, Malcolm Price,” she said.
“He’ll be handling the false allegations.”
Malcolm handed the officer a tablet.
“This video was taken yesterday outside Rosewood Clinic.”
On the screen, Lily hurried across a parking lot with Ethan crying in her arms.
The clip jumped, then showed her pulling him into the back seat of a car.
“That isn’t the full video,” Lily said.
“She cut out the part where I wrapped him in a blanket.”
Malcolm looked at me.
“Mr.
Hale, the recording on Lily’s phone was obtained unlawfully, while this video shows her removing your child without permission.”
Serena sat beside me as though we were still husband and wife.
“Come home with me,” she whispered.
“Say Lily deceived us both, and we can protect Ethan together.”
I moved my chair away.
“You’re not going near him.”
Her smile disappeared.
“Then I’ll tell the court you’re unstable.”
A child protection investigator entered and introduced herself as Dana Cole.
She spoke privately with the doctor, then returned holding a temporary safety form.
“Until we complete interviews, Ethan cannot return to the house,” Dana said.
“He’ll remain here tonight.”
“With me?” I asked.
“With hospital supervision.”
Serena lifted her chin.
“And tomorrow?”
Dana looked from Serena to Lily, then to me.
“Tomorrow, a judge will decide which story is credible.”
Malcolm closed his case with a soft click.
May you like
Serena leaned close enough that only I could hear her.
“By morning,” she whispered, “Lily’s phone won’t matter.”