Chapter 6: The Name We Had Never Heard Before

We stood there looking at that name for a long time.
Margaret Calloway.
The handwriting was our mother's.
The envelope was sealed — no, not quite.
The flap was just tucked in, not glued.
Like she had changed her mind about sealing it.
"Did she ever mention anyone named Calloway?" I asked.
"No." My brother turned the envelope over in his hands.
"But Calloway Street."
I looked at him.
"The bundle of photos," he said.
"She labeled one of them — the house on Calloway Street."
We both turned back to the bed where the photos were spread out.
He found the bundle quickly and slipped the paper label out.
*The house on Calloway Street.
1971–1979.*
"She lived on Calloway Street," I said.
"Before we were born."
"And there's a Margaret Calloway."
He set the bundle down and held the envelope again.
He wasn't opening it.
He was thinking.
"Mom was born in 1949," he said slowly.
"If this was 1971, she was twenty-two.
We weren't born until —"
"1976 and 1978," I said.
"So she lived on Calloway Street when she was in her twenties.
Before us." He paused.
"Who was she before us?"
It was a strange question.
The kind you don't think to ask until suddenly you have to.
I sat down on the edge of the bed.
"Open it," I said.
"It's addressed to someone else."
"Mom left it in a box she told us to open together.
She could have mailed it.
She could have given it to someone.
She left it here."
He looked at the envelope again.
Then he sat down beside me and opened the flap.
Inside was a single sheet of paper.
Folded once.
He unfolded it and held it so we could both read.
*"Dear Margaret,*
*I don't know if you'll ever receive this.
I don't know if you're still at the same address, or if you've moved, or if you're even still alive.
I'm writing it anyway because I've been meaning to for forty years and I've run out of time for meaning to.*
*You were my closest friend for seven years.
You were there when I had nothing and needed everything.
You fed me when I was too proud to ask for help.
You talked me through the worst night of my life and you never told a soul.
I never thanked you the way I should have.
When I moved away, I told myself I'd write, and then life moved faster than I expected, and then it had been a year, and then five, and then it felt too late.*
*It was never too late.
I just let myself believe it was because that was easier.*
*I am sorry, Margaret.
You deserved better from me.
You deserved a friend who kept her word.*
*If my children are reading this — and they might be, because I am terrible at mailing things — please find her.
If she's still there.
If she'll listen.*
*Her last known address was 414 Calloway Street.*
*All my love,*
*Ruth"*
My brother folded the letter very carefully.
"Her name was Ruth," he said.
It came out quietly, like he was saying it for the first time.
Our whole lives we had just called her Mom.
"She had a friend named Margaret," I said.
"And she never told us."
"She felt guilty about it.
For forty years."
I looked at the velvet pouch still sitting in the box.
I picked it up and loosened the drawstring.
Inside was a small brooch.
Pale blue enamel in the shape of a bird.
Old.
Delicate.
Tucked into the pouch with it was a strip of paper no bigger than a receipt.
*"This was hers.
She gave it to me when I left.
Return it if you can."*
My brother stared at the brooch in my palm.
"She wants us to find this woman," he said.
"She's asking us to finish something she couldn't."
He was quiet for a moment.
May you like
Then he stood up.
"Then I guess we find Margaret Calloway," he said.