Chapter 8: The Deposition He Didn't Expect

The formal divorce proceedings began six weeks after Emily was born.
Patricia moved quickly and precisely, exactly as she had promised.
By the time Derek's lawyer filed the first set of motions, Patricia had already submitted the financial records, the hotel receipts, the bank transfer documentation, and Margaret's preserved messages to the court.
Derek's lawyer — Todd Marsh, expensive and well-tailored and used to winning — asked for a meeting.
Patricia told me about it over the phone.
"He wants to negotiate a settlement before discovery goes further," she said.
"What does that mean?"
"It means the financial records are making Derek nervous.
Marsh has seen what we have.
He knows that if this goes to full disclosure, the asset transfers will be examined in detail.
Derek's story about the joint account becomes very hard to defend."
"So he wants to settle."
"He wants to settle on terms that still favor Derek significantly," Patricia said.
"What Marsh offered is not acceptable.
But the fact that he offered anything tells me we have leverage we didn't have a month ago."
"What happens if we don't settle?"
"We proceed to deposition.
Derek will be deposed.
So will Vanessa, potentially.
So will Margaret if she agrees." A pause.
"I think you should let it go to deposition."
"Why?"
"Because Derek has spent this entire marriage believing he is the smartest person in any room he walks into," she said.
"Depositions have a way of correcting that belief."
I agreed.
The deposition was held on a Thursday morning in a conference room in Patricia's building.
I was present.
Rachel sat beside me.
Patricia sat across from Derek and Todd Marsh.
Derek looked good.
He always looked good.
He had on the gray suit he wore to things that mattered.
His expression was composed and faintly aggrieved, the face of a man who considered himself the wronged party.
He sat down without looking at me.
Patricia opened a folder.
"Mr.
Calloway, I'd like to start with the joint bank account.
Between July and November of last year, there were eleven transfers from the joint account to a separate personal account in your name only.
Can you describe the purpose of those transfers?"
"Business expenses," Derek said.
"I've already provided documentation."
"Yes.
The documentation describes them as client entertainment and travel." Patricia set a page on the table and slid it toward him.
"This is a hotel receipt from October fourteenth.
The guest name is your personal account.
The payment method is the joint account.
The hotel is in Chicago.
Were you in Chicago for a client meeting on October fourteenth?"
Derek glanced at Marsh.
Marsh gave a small, nearly imperceptible nod.
"I travel for work frequently," Derek said.
"Were you in Chicago for a client meeting on October fourteenth?"
"I believe so."
"Can you name the client?"
A pause.
"I'd have to check my records."
"Your calendar from that period, which your employer provided to us, shows no client meeting in Chicago in October." Patricia set another page beside the first.
"What it does show is a personal calendar entry.
The entry reads: 'V — Chicago — two nights.'"
Derek's jaw moved slightly.
"Who is V, Mr.
Calloway?"
Marsh put his hand on the table.
"My client declines to—"
"We already know the answer," Patricia said pleasantly.
"I'm giving your client the opportunity to provide it himself.
That tends to look better."
The room was very quiet.
Derek's composure, which had held through the first twenty minutes, was showing the first hairline fracture.
He sat back slightly.
His right hand moved to the table and then stopped.
"Her name is Vanessa," he said.
"And the relationship was romantic."
It wasn't a question.
He answered it anyway.
"Yes."
"And this relationship began—"
"Fourteen months ago." He said it quickly.
Before Patricia could produce the messages.
As though saying it first gave him something back.
It didn't.
"Fourteen months ago," Patricia repeated.
"Which means it began approximately two months after your wife became pregnant with your daughter."
Derek said nothing.
"Mr.
Calloway, during this period, did you discuss with Vanessa any plans to restructure your personal finances in anticipation of a separation from your wife?"
Marsh leaned forward.
"My client—"
"I have the messages," Patricia said quietly.
The room went very still.
Derek looked at the table.
His face had changed completely.
The composure wasn't cracked anymore.
It was gone.
"Yes," he said.
Quietly.
Almost to himself.
"And did those plans include removing funds from the marital estate before your wife had any knowledge of your intention to separate?"
Marsh closed his folder.
"We'd like to request a short recess," he said.
Patricia looked at him.
"Of course," she said.
She gathered her papers without hurrying.
I watched Derek across the table.
He was staring at a point on the wall somewhere to the left of my face.
Not at me.
He couldn't quite bring himself to look at me.
I didn't look away from him.
May you like
He had walked into this room believing he was still the smartest person in it.
He was wrong.