Chapter 5: What Claire Agreed To

Eleanor pulled her sleeve over the bracelet.
“Thousands of women own one like this.”
Officer Ruiz froze the image.
Three engraved charms hung from the chain: a heart, a key, and the letter C.
I looked at Eleanor’s wrist.
The same three charms rested against her hand.
“You were in the nursery.”
“I visited earlier,” she said.
“That proves nothing.”
“You said you weren’t in the house.”
“I was confused by all the shouting.”
Jamie stood beside me.
“You said I was confused.”
Eleanor’s cheeks tightened.
“Do not speak to me that way.”
Claire stepped between them.
“Everyone needs to calm down.”
I faced her.
“Did you know your mother was there?”
“No.”
“Jamie heard you talking to her.”
“He misheard us.”
“Then there was an ‘us.’”
Claire looked toward the interview-room door.
Officer Ruiz placed a tablet on the table.
“This device was synced to your phone, Claire.
We have recovered messages deleted after the ambulance left.”
Claire reached for it.
Ruiz moved it out of reach.
The first message had been sent by Claire at 7:46 p.m.
BRING THE EMPTY BOTTLE.
I NEED HIM TO UNDERSTAND JAMIE CANNOT STAY HERE.
Eleanor’s answer appeared beneath it.
LEAVE IT TO ME.
BY MORNING, HE’LL FINALLY CHOOSE HIS WIFE.
My hand tightened around the chair.
“You planned this?”
Claire began to cry.
“Not what happened to Sophie.”
“What did you plan?”
“I wanted you to find an empty bottle near the crib.
I was going to say Jamie must have dropped it.”
Jamie stared at her.
“You wanted him to think I hurt Sophie?”
“No.
I only wanted him to believe you were careless.”
“That is the same thing,” I said.
Claire wiped her face.
“You always choose Jamie.
Every holiday, every phone call, every emergency—he comes first.”
“He is my brother.”
“And I’m your wife!”
Jamie flinched.
I lowered my voice.
“You could have told me you felt neglected.
Instead, you tried to frame a vulnerable man.”
“I was frightened.”
“No.
You were ashamed of him.”
Claire’s hand fell from her face.
“I was,” she whispered.
“I looked at Jamie and saw everything that could go wrong.
Then I treated every kind thing he did as another danger.”
Jamie’s eyes filled.
“You didn’t want me in the picture.”
Claire covered her mouth.
“You said I wasn’t normal,” he continued.
“But I never made Sophie unsafe.
You did.”
Her knees gave way, and she sat hard against the wall.
“I’m sorry.”
Jamie shook his head.
“Sorry is after you spill soup.
This is bigger.”
Eleanor reached for her handbag.
“My daughter was under pressure.
Her husband refused to protect his own family.”
Officer Ruiz blocked the door.
“Sit down, Mrs.
Walsh.”
“I have nothing else to say.”
“We recovered more than messages.”
Claire looked up.
“What else?”
Ruiz placed another evidence bag on the table.
Inside was the supposedly empty bottle from the nursery.
“The pharmacy counted the remaining tablets against the refill record.
This bottle was never empty.”
Claire turned slowly toward her mother.
“You told me it was.”
Eleanor did not answer.
Officer Ruiz tapped the screen again.
“At 1:48 a.m., the front-door camera recorded someone returning to the house.
We also recovered a second nursery clip.”
May you like
Eleanor’s hand stopped halfway to her handbag.
This time, the video showed her face.