Spotlight

Chapter 4: What I Never Told Them

My name is Daniel Mercer.

I am fifty-four years old.

I have six daughters, no savings worth mentioning, a twelve-year-old truck, and a very small house that still smells faintly of the strawberry shampoo six girls went through at a remarkable rate for about a decade.

I am not a complicated man.

But I kept one secret, and Elena found it, and I should explain what it was — because when it came out that night, it did not come out the way she intended.

When Elena left, Chloe was nine.

Diane was seven.

The twins, Meg and Jo, were five.

Sophie was three.

Rosie was nine months old.

Six girls, the oldest of whom understood exactly what had happened, and the youngest of whom would have no memory of her mother at all.

For the first two years, I barely slept.

I worked the early shift at a warehouse and the evening shift at a grocery store.

My sister Carol came on Tuesdays.

A neighbor, Mrs.

Patterson, watched the babies on weekday mornings for sixty dollars a week, which was everything I had, and she never once raised the price even when things got harder.

In the third year, I made a decision I never told the girls about.

A lawyer contacted me.

Elena's name was on a life insurance policy I hadn't known existed — a small one, taken out before we married, with me listed as the secondary beneficiary.

The primary was her mother, who had recently passed away.

By the terms of the policy, the benefit now passed to me.

Eleven thousand dollars.

It was not a fortune.

But in that third year, it was the difference between keeping the house and losing it.

I took the money.

I paid off four months of arrears on the mortgage.

I bought the girls winter coats.

I fixed the furnace.

I never told them where the money came from because I did not want them to feel any connection to Elena.

I did not want them thinking about her.

I wanted her to be, as much as possible, simply gone.

That was the secret.

Not a crime.

Not a betrayal.

Not anything close to what Elena's expression in that room had suggested.

But the way Elena had looked at me — that particular angle of her chin, the slow turning of the envelope — told me she had found something and built a story around it.

A story in which I had done something unforgivable with that money.

A story in which I was the villain.

I knew this because Elena had always been very good at finding the part of the truth that could be shaped into something else.

At the reception dinner, she was seated three tables away.

I could see her from where I sat.

She had not opened the envelope.

She was speaking to a woman I didn't recognize — someone from Julian's side, I assumed — and she was smiling the way she smiled when she was calculating something.

Sophie, sitting beside me, leaned over.

"Dad.

What's in that envelope?"

"Something old," I said.

"That's not an answer."

"No."

She studied me for a moment.

Sophie was twenty-one.

She had Elena's coloring and my stubbornness, which had made her childhood interesting.

"Are you scared of her?" she asked.

I thought about it honestly.

"No," I said.

"I'm scared of what she'll do to your sisters."

Sophie nodded slowly.

She picked up her fork.

"Then we won't let her."

I looked at her.

She was already eating, as if the matter were settled.

Perhaps it was.

But after dinner, when the tables were being cleared and the dancing started, I watched Elena excuse herself from her companion and walk toward the far side of the room — toward Chloe, who was standing near the window with her new husband, Marcus.

Elena touched Chloe's arm.

Chloe turned.

I couldn't hear what Elena said.

But I watched Chloe's expression change.

That careful composure — the composure she had worn all day like armor — slipped for just a moment.

May you like

Just long enough for me to see what was underneath it.

And then Marcus excused himself, and Elena leaned close to Chloe, and she opened the envelope at last.

Related Stories

Other posts