Chapter 3: The Lie at the Table

Mr.
Russo slipped the envelope into his jacket.
“I promised no such thing, Daniel.”
Dad crossed the dining room.
“You stood in my kitchen after Margaret’s funeral and told me every copy had been destroyed.”
“Dad, what is he talking about?”
He stopped beside me but kept his eyes on Mr.
Russo.
“Give Anna the letter, Victor.”
“So she can learn what kind of man raised her?”
Sophie stepped between them.
“Father, please.”
I stared at her.
“He’s your father?”
“And Eleanor was my mother,” she said.
Mr.
Russo seized her arm.
“Go back to work.”
Sophie pulled free.
“Don’t touch me.”
Dad held out his hand.
“The letter.”
Mr.
Russo laughed and passed me the envelope.
The paper inside had been copied so many times that the words were blurred.
One sentence had been underlined in red.
If Daniel Bennett ever asks a woman to trust him, tell her what he did to me.
“What did you do?” I asked.
“Nothing that letter claims.”
“Then why didn’t you tell me about Eleanor?”
Dad lowered himself into the corner booth.
“Eleanor and Victor owned this restaurant.
Your mother managed the accounts, and I handled repairs.
We were friends before this place opened.”
“Friends don’t write warnings like that,” Mr.
Russo said.
Dad’s fist came down on the table.
“You dictated it.”
The silverware jumped.
Sophie covered her mouth.
Mr.
Russo leaned closer.
“Careful, Daniel.
Accusing me won’t make the letter disappear.”
“Eleanor told Margaret you forced her to sign it.”
“My wife was confused.”
“She was frightened of you.”
Mr.
Russo smiled at me.
“Ask your father why Eleanor’s signature was witnessed by two people.”
Dad turned toward Sophie.
“Who were they?”
“Two former employees,” she said.
“Both moved away before I was born.”
“Convenient,” I said.
Mr.
Russo took back the page.
“Seven sensible women read Eleanor’s warning.
Seven made their own decision.”
“You gave it to them deliberately,” I said.
“I protected them.”
“From my father—or from questions about you?”
His smile disappeared.
Sophie opened the register drawer and pulled out a small notebook.
Seven names and phone numbers filled the first page.
“You made me record every woman,” she said.
“You told me Dad had cheated Mother and that I owed it to her.”
“You did owe it to her.”
“No.” Sophie’s voice shook.
“You used me.”
Mr.
Russo snatched for the notebook, but I took it first.
“Anna, give that back,” he said.
“How do you know my name?”
The room went quiet.
Dad rose slowly.
“I never told you her name.”
Mr.
Russo looked toward the kitchen.
Sophie backed away from him.
“He has a file in his office.
There are photographs of your house, your car, and your father.”
Dad stepped in front of me.
“You’ve been watching my daughter?”
“I’ve been protecting my business.”
“From what?”
Mr.
Russo’s eyes settled on Dad.
“From Margaret’s final mistake.”
I gripped Dad’s sleeve.
“What mistake?”
He closed his eyes.
“Your mother found proof that Eleanor’s letter was false.”
“Where is it?”
May you like
Dad looked at me, and the fear in his face was worse than anything written on that page.
“She hid it in your house.”