Chapter 8: What Sophie and Ella Decided

I told them that evening at the dinner table.
Sophie put her fork down when I mentioned the watch.
She didn't pick it up again for a while.
Ella kept eating.
Her jaw was tighter than usual, which meant she was thinking hard about something she wasn't saying yet.
"She kept it," Sophie said.
"For twelve years."
"Yes."
"She could have sold it at any point.
Used the money for something."
"She could have," I said.
"But she didn't."
"No."
Sophie looked at her plate.
"I don't know what to do with that."
"You don't have to do anything with it tonight," I said.
Ella set her fork down.
"I want to see her," she said.
"I've been thinking about it since she left on Sunday and I keep coming back to the same answer.
I want to see her in person.
Not just once because she showed up at the door.
I want to actually sit with her and ask her the things I haven't been able to ask in letters."
"What things?" Sophie asked.
Ella looked at her sister.
"Whether she was scared.
When she was with us, before the accident, before all of it.
Whether she was already frightened then and nobody knew.
Because if she was—" Ella stopped.
"I want to know if there was a version of this where someone could have seen it in time."
The table was quiet.
Sophie picked up her fork.
Set it back down again.
"I want to see her too," she said finally.
"But I want it to be on our terms.
I don't want her to arrive and have it feel like she's the one setting the conditions."
"That's reasonable," I said.
"Can you tell her that?
That we're open to it, but we choose the place and the time?"
"Yes."
"And Daddy." Sophie looked at me directly.
"What do you want?
Not what you'll support us in.
What do you actually want?"
It was a good question.
It was the question I had been waiting for one of them to ask.
"I want to understand it better," I said.
"The night she left.
The logic of it.
I've had twelve years to be angry at a note, and now I'm being asked to replace that with something more complicated.
I need time to do that at my own pace."
"That's allowed," Ella said, as if she was giving me permission, which in some quiet way she was.
"I'll call her tomorrow," I said.
"Tell her you're open to meeting.
Tell her we'll set the time."
Both of them nodded.
We finished dinner.
Sophie washed up.
Ella dried.
I sat at the kitchen table with my coffee and watched them move around each other the way they always had, the small efficient choreography of two people who have shared a space their whole lives.
Sophie handed a plate to Ella without looking.
Ella caught it without looking.
They had always done that.
Even at six years old with crayon drawings on the refrigerator, they had always moved through the same space as if they were two halves of one continuous awareness.
Rebecca had missed all of it.
Every version of this ordinary evening, twelve years of them, was something she would never get back.
That was a consequence she was living inside of right now.
It was not nothing.
---
Three weeks later, we met her at a small restaurant near the river.
Neutral ground, Sophie had said, and Rebecca had agreed to it without negotiation.
She arrived before us and was already seated when we came through the door.
She stood when she saw us.
She was wearing a plain blue sweater.
Her hands were at her sides.
Ella walked up to her first.
She didn't hug her immediately.
She stood in front of her and looked at her carefully for a moment, the way you look at something you have been trying to picture for a long time.
Then she reached out and took Rebecca's hand with both of hers.
Rebecca's face did not collapse.
It went very still, the way faces go still when they are trying to hold something enormous without breaking it.
"Hi," Ella said.
"Hi," Rebecca said.
Sophie came up beside Ella and stood there.
She didn't take Rebecca's other hand, but she put her arm briefly around Ella's shoulders and nodded at Rebecca, which was a kind of permission.
I sat down at the table.
They sat down.
A waiter appeared.
We ordered coffee.
Outside the window, the river moved slowly in the late afternoon light.
A dog ran along the far bank.
"Thank you for coming," Rebecca said.
"We wanted to," Ella said.
And then Sophie, who had been the more careful one through all of it, opened the menu and looked across at Rebecca.
"What are you having?" she asked.
It was not forgiveness.
May you like
It was not a closed door either.
It was two people sitting across a table with their mother, deciding, one ordinary question at a time, what kind of future was still possible.