Chapter 5: Patricia's Story

Patricia Holt-Warren answered on the second ring.
Her voice was measured and careful, the voice of someone who had learned not to lead with emotion.
She sounded like she was in her mid-forties, and she spoke the way people do when they have had a long time to organize a story that still makes them angry.
*"How much do you already know?"* she asked.
*"Only what my mother wrote in a letter,"* I said.
*"She knew a woman named Cresswell in Portland.
She saw what happened with your father.
She tried to warn mine."*
A pause.
*"Your mother sounds like she was a good woman."*
*"She was."*
*"All right,"* Patricia said.
*"Then I'll tell you the rest."*
She told me that Maria — Cresswell at the time — had appeared in their neighborhood when Patricia's father was two years into widowhood.
Gerald Holt was not a foolish man.
He was a retired contractor who had built a small property management company from nothing.
He had owned three rental houses outright and had a comfortable savings.
He was also, Patricia said, desperately lonely.
*"She came to one of the neighborhood block events,"* Patricia said.
*"Nobody knew who she had.
She introduced herself as a recently divorced woman who'd just moved to the area.
She was friendly, well-dressed.
Dad noticed her immediately."*
*"How long before she moved in?"*
*"Seven months."*
I wrote the number down.
*"He was completely charmed,"* Patricia continued.
*"And I — I was living in Salem by then.
I came to visit and I didn't like her, but I couldn't put my finger on why.
She was always very warm to my face.
Very interested in me.
Asked about my children, my marriage.
It felt like she was gathering information, but I couldn't say that to my father without sounding jealous."*
*"What did she do with the finances?"*
Patricia exhaled.
*"She convinced him to open a joint account for household expenses.
Said it was simpler.
Said she didn't want him to feel like she was a guest in her own home.
Very reasonable.
Very practical."* Her voice went flat.
*"Over the next eight months, she transferred just enough, just frequently enough, that it didn't look unusual.
Small amounts.
Groceries.
Car repairs.
A dental bill.
Nothing that would trigger any alarms on its own."*
*"Until it added up."*
*"Until it added up,"* Patricia confirmed.
*"When she left, the joint account was drained.
Two of the three rental properties had been quietly listed as collateral on a personal loan she'd taken out in both their names.
Dad hadn't fully understood what he was signing.
She's good, Zoe.
She makes you feel like you're the one being slow if you ask too many questions."*
I thought of my father — a man who had spent years waving away every concern I raised with *stop being so sensitive.*
*"How much?"* I asked.
*"In total?
Somewhere around two hundred and forty thousand dollars.
By the time it was untangled and the loan was resolved, Dad had one rental property left and about thirty thousand in savings.
He went from comfortable retirement to counting every month."*
*"Did you go to the police?"*
*"We tried."* Patricia's voice tightened.
*"She was careful.
Every transfer was from a joint account he had agreed to open.
The loan had his signature.
She hadn't forged anything — she'd just made him sign things he didn't fully read.
The detective we spoke to said it was a civil matter, not a crjminal one.
The civil case would have cost more than it was worth to pursue."*
*"So she walked away clean."*
*"She walked away and disappeared.
Changed her name, apparently."* A beat.
*"Until now."*
I told Patricia about the property search printout.
The date.
Sixteen years ago.
My mother's address.
The line went very quiet.
*"She researched your family before your father even met her?"*
*"Yes."*
*"She knew your mother was ill?"*
*"We think so."*
Another long pause.
*"Then she planned it,"* Patricia said.
*"All of it.
She didn't stumble into your father's life.
She targeted him.
She waited for your mother to be g\*ne and then she moved."*
*"Yes."*
*"Zoe."* Patricia's voice was different now.
Something had cracked open slightly in it.
*"I spent years wondering if I was wrong about her.
Wondering if she had just been a troubled woman who made bad choices.
I used to think that because it was easier than the alternative."*
*"What's the alternative?"*
*"That she's done this before us.
And after us.
That it's not something she fell into.
It's something she does."*
The room felt very still.
*"Would you be willing to speak with my father's attorney?"* I asked.
*"Yes,"* Patricia said immediately.
*"Yes.
I have documents.
I kept everything.
I don't know what good they do at this point, but I kept them."*
*"They may do a great deal of good."*
I gave her Ellsworth's contact information.
After we hung up, I sat for a moment without moving.
My father was in the next room.
I could hear the quiet sound of the television, turned low — the same sound from a different house, a different life ago.
I picked up the letter again.
My mother's second page.
The uneven handwriting, the pressed letters.
*Please remember that Zoe is your daughter.*
*I am only asking you to see her.*
I folded it carefully and set it back down.
Then I went to the doorway of the living room.
Dad looked up from the television.
The remote was in his hand but the screen might as well have been blank.
*"I just got off the phone with Patricia Holt-Warren,"* I said.
He sat up.
*"She'll talk to Ellsworth.
She has documents."*
He let out a slow breath.
*"And she confirmed it,"* I continued.
*"Maria targeted you deliberately.
The property search proves she was watching our family before Mom d\*ed.
Patricia's story proves this isn't the first time."*
Dad set the remote down on the cushion beside him.
He looked at me for a long moment.
*"What do we do now?"*
I leaned against the doorframe.
*"Now we find out if there were others,"* I said.
*"Between Portland and Austin.
Between Gerald Holt and you."*
He blinked.
*"You think there were more?"*
*"She's careful,"* I said.
*"She's organized.
She changes her name.
She researches her targets in advance."* I paused.
*"People who are that systematic don't usually stop at two."*
My father looked like the floor had shifted underneath him.
*"How do we find them?"*
I looked back at the laptop on my desk.
*"The same way I found Patricia,"* I said.
*"We look."*
I turned back toward my desk.
But then my phone buzzed.
I glanced at the screen.
An unknown number.
Texas area code.
I answered it.
The voice on the other end was Hazel's.
*"Zoe,"* she said, without preamble, without warmth.
*"I know Dad is with you.
May you like
You need to send him home.
This has gone far enough."*