Spotlight

Chapter 9: What Sandra Did Next

Sandra's attorney sent a response letter ten days later.

Grace called to tell me.

I was at the coffee shop two blocks from Patrice's place, the one with the corner table that got good morning light, where I'd started going most days with my laptop and the printed copy of my trust documents and a growing list of questions that Grace answered by email with a speed and precision that still surprised me.

"She's disputing the harm claim," Grace said.

"Arguing that you had access to employment, housing, and educational support through the family home and that the trust, while not disclosed, did not materially deprive you of necessities."

"She's saying I had a roof over my head so it doesn't count."

"In considerably more legal language, yes.

That is the argument."

I looked out the window.

A woman was walking a dog so small it looked like a mistake.

A very confident mistake, pulling hard at the leash.

"What does that mean for us?" I asked.

"It means she's going to fight it, at least initially.

This is standard.

The first response is almost never an admission.

What it tells me is that she spoke to a competent attorney who gave her a defensible opening position." Grace paused.

"What it also tells me is that she's worried.

Because if she weren't, the response would have been a flat refusal to engage."

"She's worried," I repeated.

"She engaged.

That's the tell."

"What's our next step?"

"I'd like to request the financial records from the household for the past four years.

Specifically, anything that touched your expenses — tuition payments, the roof over your head she's now citing, grocery contributions, anything that can be documented.

If she's going to argue you were provided for, I want to see what that actually looked like against what you were earning and saving yourself."

"My pay stubs," I said.

"I kept all of them."

"Of course you did." Grace's voice had a warmth in it that I was starting to recognize.

"Send them to me.

Everything."

After I hung up, I stayed at the corner table and watched the street.

My phone buzzed.

A number I didn't recognize.

I answered.

"Claire." Sandra's voice.

Measured.

Careful.

Dressed up the same way her face always was when she was about to explain why she was right.

I didn't say anything.

"I think we should talk," she said.

"Directly.

Before this becomes something neither of us can undo."

"It already is something neither of us can undo," I said.

"I mean legally.

I mean — Claire, there are things about your mother's letter that you don't fully understand.

Things she wrote that I interpreted in good faith.

I was trying to —"

"Sandra." I kept my voice level.

"Did my mother ask you to tell me about the trust when I turned eighteen?"

Silence.

"Did she ask you, yes or no?"

"It was more complicated than —"

"Yes or no."

A longer silence.

"Yes," she said finally.

"Did you tell me?"

Nothing.

"I didn't think so," I said.

"My attorney will be in touch."

I hung up.

My coffee had gone cold.

I drank it anyway.

Then I opened my email and started drafting the message to Grace about the pay stubs.

May you like

I had kept every single one.

Of course I had.

Related Stories

Other posts