Chapter 9: What Justice Cost

Three weeks later, I sat in the same courthouse while Diane entered her plea.
Chloe sat on one side of me and Evelyn on the other.
The judge looked over the agreement.
“You are pleading guilty to forgery, attempted property fraud, and witness interference?”
Diane’s jaw tightened.
“Yes.”
“You will serve twelve months in county custody, followed by three years of supervised probation.
You will pay restitution and have no contact with Nia Carter.”
Diane glanced toward Chloe.
“And my daughter?”
“Ms.
Chloe Bennett is an adult.
She has requested no contact for the present time.”
Chloe’s fingers closed around mine.
The judge looked at my father next.
“Martin Carter, your cooperation does not erase your conduct.”
“I understand.”
“You will receive five years of probation, two hundred hours of community service, and joint responsibility for restitution.
You are also prohibited from handling trust property.”
My father nodded.
“I accept that.”
Outside the courtroom, Diane was allowed a brief moment with Chloe before officers took her away.
“You let Nia turn you against me,” Diane said.
Chloe shook her head.
“Nia never asked me to choose.”
“She will throw you out when she gets tired of playing the hero.”
“I offered Chloe a written lease,” I said.
“She refused it.”
Diane frowned.
Chloe took a folded paper from her bag.
“Because I found a room near the community college.
Nia helped me pay the deposit, but I signed the lease myself.”
“You cannot manage on your own.”
“I found a job at Evelyn’s office.”
Evelyn smiled.
“Part-time filing work.
Nothing she has not earned.”
Diane looked from one face to another.
“You all want me to beg.”
“No,” Chloe said.
“I want you to admit you used me.”
“I protected you.”
“You opened a fraudulent account in my name.”
“I was securing your future.”
“You told Nia I was taking her room.
You told Martin people were coming after me.
You told the bank I knew about the money.
Which part protected me?”
Diane’s face hardened.
“Someday you will understand what a mother has to do.”
Chloe wiped one tear from her cheek.
“My mother should never have made me afraid to tell the truth.”
The officer touched Diane’s arm.
She resisted for one second, then looked at me.
“You won the house, Nia.
I hope it keeps you warm when everyone leaves.”
I opened the courthouse door for the officer.
“My mother left me more than a house.”
Diane walked through without another word.
My father waited beside the steps.
He held a small suitcase because I had required him to move out before the hearing.
“I found an apartment,” he said.
“It is not far.”
“That is good.”
“May I call you?”
“Not yet.”
He nodded, then took an envelope from his coat.
“This is my first restitution payment.
I sold my car.”
I did not take it immediately.
“You cannot buy forgiveness.”
“I know.” He placed the envelope in Evelyn’s hand.
“But I can begin paying what I owe.”
Chloe stepped away to give us space.
My father looked at me.
“I loved your mother, Nia.
I also betrayed her.
Both things are true, and saying the first does not excuse the second.”
“Why did you choose Diane?”
“Because Diane made every wrong choice sound temporary.
One signature.
One lie.
One dinner where I looked away.”
“And Mom?”
“Laura asked me to be brave when being brave would cost me something.
I failed.”
My throat tightened.
“You did not only fail her.
You watched me ask whether you wanted me gone.”
“I know.”
“You nodded.”
He lowered his head.
“I hear that chair scraping every night.”
Tears filled my eyes, and Chloe returned to my side.
She put one arm around me without speaking.
“I cannot forgive you today,” I told my father.
“I am not asking you to.”
“But if you keep telling the truth, perhaps one day we can sit together without that dinner between us.”
He looked up.
“That is more than I deserve.”
“It is not a promise.
It is a door you will have to earn the right to approach.”
“I understand.”
He lifted his suitcase and walked toward the bus stop.
At the corner, he turned, but he did not wave.
I did not wave either.
Chloe leaned against me.
“Do you think people really change?” she asked.
“I think they reveal it one choice at a time.”
My phone rang.
The estate agent’s name appeared on the screen.
“I have an offer on the house,” she said.
“It is well above the asking price.”
Chloe looked at me.
“You’re selling?”
I stared back at the courthouse doors.
May you like
“No,” I said.
“But I know what I want to do with it.”