Chapter 4: Two Mothers, One Child

Claire arrived at the station before sunrise.
She was pale, with a healing scar above the collar of her blouse, and she stopped the moment she saw Noah in Margaret’s arms.
“My baby.”
Noah opened his eyes at the sound of her voice.
I tightened my hold on his blanket.
“I didn’t know.”
Claire crossed the room, then halted before reaching for him.
“You called him Noah?”
“Daniel told me his name was Benjamin.”
Her hand covered her mouth.
Margaret touched my shoulder.
“Let her sit beside you.”
Claire lowered herself into the next chair.
“His father chose Noah before he passed away.
Daniel knew that.”
“You knew Daniel before this?”
“He handled payroll at the company where I worked.
Vanessa approached me after my surgery and said he could arrange temporary care.”
Officer Reed placed a clear evidence sleeve on the table.
“Is this your signature?”
Claire studied the document.
“The first page is mine.
The surrender page isn’t.”
I looked at Noah’s face.
“I bought his crib.
I took him to every appointment.
I sang to him when he woke at night.”
Claire’s eyes filled, but she held out her hand to me instead of taking him.
“Then he was loved while I couldn’t reach him.”
That kindness broke the last piece of strength I had left.
My shoulders folded, and Claire caught Noah between us while Margaret held me.
“I’m sorry,” I sobbed.
“I would never have kept him from you.”
“I know,” Claire said.
“Daniel needed us to hate each other.
We’re not going to give him that.”
A child-services worker entered and knelt beside Lily.
“Would you like to stay with Grandma Margaret tonight?”
Lily nodded, then looked at me.
“Is Mommy coming?”
“I’ll be right there.”
The worker glanced at her notes.
“For now, visits must be supervised until we understand who signed the placement documents.”
Daniel’s accusation had worked.
I could not take Lily home, and I could not leave with the baby I had raised.
Lily reached for me.
“Please don’t choose the baby again.”
I dropped to my knees.
“What do you mean?”
“Daddy said you loved him more.
He said if I told you about Grandma Vanessa, you’d send me away so he could have my room.”
“No.” I gathered Lily into my arms.
“I should have seen you were frightened.
But you never had to earn your place with me.”
“Do you believe me now?”
“I believe every word.”
My phone rang inside the evidence tray.
Officer Reed checked the screen.
“It’s Vanessa.
We can answer on speaker if you consent.”
I nodded.
Vanessa’s voice came through cold and steady.
“Withdraw your statement, tell Claire the arrangement was your idea, and Daniel will let you keep Lily.”
“You don’t get to bargain with my daughter.”
“I have your signatures.
I have messages showing how badly you wanted another child.”
“You forged the surrender papers.”
“Prove it.”
Claire leaned toward the phone.
“I will.”
Vanessa laughed.
“You can’t even prove where you were the night your signature appeared.”
Officer Reed’s expression changed.
“What night?” he asked.
Vanessa ended the call.
A clerk hurried into the room with a newly filed envelope.
May you like
“Daniel has requested an emergency custody hearing,” she said.
“He claims his wife organized the illegal placement—and that Lily is unsafe with her.”