Spotlight

Chapter 7: What the Attorney Found

Monday came cold and clear.

I dropped Lily at school and drove directly to Gerald Hatch's office on Bresford Street.

Dad was already in the waiting room when I arrived, sitting with his coat still on, reading nothing.

Gerald came out himself to get us.

He was sixty-something, unhurried, the kind of attorney who made you feel like the situation was serious but not out of control.

I had liked him from the moment Dad introduced us, two years ago, at a completely different kind of meeting — a will update that Diane had pushed for and Dad had agreed to.

That was the first item on today's list.

Gerald's office had two windows.

We sat across the desk from him.

He had a folder open in front of him, thick with paper.

"I'll start with the good news," Gerald said.

"The Scottsdale deed reversal is clean.

The notary cooperated fully once we presented the timeline inconsistency.

The property is entirely in your name again, Richard.

That closed Friday."

Dad nodded.

"The will amendment," Gerald continued, "is a separate matter, but a simpler one.

The version Diane presented for signing in February of last year — the one that would have moved thirty percent of the primary estate into a joint account in her name upon your death — was signed during your post-surgery recovery period." He paused.

"You were on significant pain management.

There is a credible argument that your capacity at the time of signing was compromised.

We are voiding it."

"She brought the papers to the hospital," Dad said.

It wasn't a question.

"She did."

I looked at the desk.

My hands were flat on my knees.

"She brought legal documents to a man recovering from hip surgery," I said, "and told him to sign."

"That appears to be what happened," Gerald said.

He said it carefully, without drama, which somehow made it worse.

"What about the accounts?" Dad asked.

"Three transfers over fourteen months.

Total: forty-one thousand dollars, moved from your primary savings into a secondary account opened in Diane's name only." Gerald turned a page.

"The account was opened five days after your wedding."

The room was very quiet.

"She planned it before the wedding," Dad said.

"The account opening date suggests that, yes."

Dad sat back.

He looked at the ceiling for a moment.

Then he looked back at Gerald.

"And Carol?"

Gerald's expression stayed even.

"Carol Prentiss introduced the two of you in April, four years ago, at an event she organized.

We have found no direct financial connection between Mrs.

Prentiss and Diane at this time.

However—" He turned another page.

"—Mrs.

Prentiss made three phone calls to Diane in the forty-eight hours following each of the fourteen-month transfers.

The timing is consistent enough to be significant."

"Consistent enough for legal action?" I asked.

"Consistent enough to warrant further investigation.

Whether it becomes actionable depends on what that investigation finds." He looked at Dad.

"It's your call."

Dad was quiet for a moment.

"She sat in the front row at my wife's funeral," he said.

"I know," Gerald said.

Gently.

"Eleanor would have been devastated."

I said nothing.

Because he was right.

My mother had trusted Carol with things she hadn't trusted to anyone else — the particular loneliness of the last year of her illness, the fears she hadn't wanted to burden us with.

And Carol had sat with all of that, nodded, held her hand.

And then had called Diane three days after every bank transfer.

"Investigate," Dad said.

"Everything you can find."

Gerald made a note.

"There's one more item," he said.

He turned to the last section of the folder.

"Diane's attorney contacted my office this morning.

She is proposing a settlement.

She will return the forty-one thousand, deed over any remaining claim on the Mayvale account, and sign a full release — in exchange for you not pursuing fraud charges."

Dad looked at him.

"She's frightened," Gerald said.

"She should be."

"The offer does have some practical merit," Gerald said, in the tone of a man doing his job.

"A civil case would cost time, money, and energy.

A settlement would close it faster and cleanly."

"What does pursuing charges accomplish beyond the settlement?" I asked.

"A formal record," Gerald said.

"And possible referral to the DA's office if the document forgery rises to criminal thresholds." He looked at Dad.

"The notary's cooperation means that threshold is within reach."

Dad tapped his finger once on the arm of the chair.

"Tell her attorney she has seventy-two hours to return the money in full.

After that, we don't settle." He stood up.

"And the fraud referral proceeds regardless."

Gerald nodded.

Closed the folder.

I stood up too.

Outside in the corridor, waiting for the elevator, Dad said nothing for a long moment.

Then: "Your mother would have seen through her immediately."

"Yes," I said.

"She would have."

"She always said Carol was a person who needed to be useful to people who mattered." He pressed the elevator button.

"I never understood what she meant until now."

The elevator opened.

We rode down in silence.

And in the lobby, as we pushed through the glass door into the cold morning air, my phone buzzed.

A message from a number I didn't recognize.

*You don't know me.

But I worked with Diane for six years.

May you like

I have something you need to see.

Please call.*

Related Stories

Other posts