Spotlight

Chapter 6: What Paige Needed to Say First

We met at a coffee shop in neutral territory — a town neither of us lived in, halfway between the rental and the family home.

Paige was there when I arrived.

She had chosen a table near the back, away from the windows, and she was not wearing her coat the way Aunt Renee had been — she was wearing it the way someone wears a coat when they've been sitting somewhere for a long time and haven't noticed they're still in it.

She looked like she hadn't slept.

I sat down across from her.

"You said you needed to tell me something before I heard it somewhere else," I said.

"So tell me."

She wrapped both hands around her coffee cup.

"I put the runner there."

I waited.

"It wasn't already there.

Mom had it folded in the linen closet.

I took it out the night before Christmas and put it on the stairs.

I knew your heel always catches on runner edges.

You've tripped on them before." She said it flat, fast, like ripping something off.

"It was supposed to be a stumble.

Something embarrassing.

Not—" She stopped.

"I didn't think you'd go down the whole flight."

The coffee shop was warm and smelled like cinnamon and other people's normal mornings.

"You set it up," I said.

"Yes."

"So I'd fall."

"So you'd look clumsy.

So you'd be flustered.

So when I brought up the house later that day — I was going to bring it up, I had a whole thing planned — you'd be off balance." She pressed her lips together.

"It was stupid and it was cruel and you ended up with a broken wrist and I watched you lie on the floor and I still laughed because everyone else was laughing and I didn't know what else to do."

I looked at her.

"You didn't know what else to do."

"I know how that sounds."

"Do you?"

She looked down.

"I panicked.

I knew the moment you hit the tile that it had gone too far.

But by then Mom was already saying her thing about you being dramatic, and Dad was covering his face, and if I'd broken from it right then — they would have known I'd planned it.

And then everything with the house would have come out, and—"

"And you would have been caught."

"Yes."

"So you laughed."

"Yes."

I sat with that for a moment.

"Paige.

I drove myself to urgent care with a fractured wrist.

One-handed.

In the dark.

On Christmas night.

Because not a single person in that house asked if I was all right."

Her jaw worked.

"I know."

"Do you also know that a fall like that, at the wrong angle, could have been a great deal worse?"

She didn't answer.

But her eyes filled — fast, involuntary — and she looked away to stop it.

"Why are you telling me this now?" I asked.

"Because Eleanor Marsh called Mom this morning." Paige's voice steadied back into something harder.

"She filed something on the house.

An injunction, or — I don't know the exact word.

Mom called me in a panic.

She and Dad are talking about challenging it.

They've been on the phone with someone, some other attorney, since this morning." She paused.

"And they told him the fall was an accident.

They told him you tripped.

They are going to use the accident to argue you're—" She stopped.

"To argue I'm what?"

Paige looked at me directly.

"Unstable.

That you're acting out of spite because you've always been difficult.

That the fall made you irrational."

The cinnamon smell.

The warm room.

The sound of someone ordering a latte at the counter.

"They're going to use my broken wrist — that they caused — to argue against me in a legal dispute over a house that is half mine."

"Yes."

"And you're here because—"

"Because I'm not doing that with them." Something in her face had tightened into something I didn't recognize.

Not guilt, exactly.

Resolve.

"I'm not signing anything that says you tripped.

I'm not giving a statement that says it was an accident." She reached into her bag and set a folded piece of paper on the table.

"I wrote down what I did.

The runner.

Everything.

I had it notarized this morning."

I looked at the paper without touching it.

"Why?" I said.

"Because Mason saw me put it on the stairs." Her voice dropped.

"He came down for water the night before.

He didn't say anything but he saw me.

And he's eight years old and I am not going to let my eight-year-old son carry that for the rest of his life to protect me."

The table was very still.

"Give me your attorney's number," Paige said.

"I want to give my statement to her directly.

Not through Mom's people.

Not through anyone else." She pushed the folded paper an inch closer to me.

"And Claire — I need you to know that I'm sorry.

Not because of the legal situation.

Because what I did was wrong.

It was wrong before you fell and it was wrong after and I knew it the whole time."

I looked at my sister.

I had known her my entire life.

I had watched her be careless and calculating in the same breath since we were children.

I had watched her choose the version of events that suited her without blinking.

I didn't know yet what to do with this version of her.

But I picked up the notarized statement.

And I gave her Eleanor Marsh's number.

"She'll want to speak with you before the end of the week," I said.

Paige nodded.

She was already reaching for her phone.

"Claire." She stopped before dialing.

"Mom and Dad's attorney — he pushed them to act fast.

He told them to move on the property this week.

Before the injunction is formally processed." Her voice was careful.

"I don't know what that means legally.

But he told them there was still a window."

I stood up and put on my coat.

"There isn't," I said.

"Eleanor already closed it."

But when I stepped outside into the cold morning air, I pulled out my own phone and called Eleanor anyway.

She answered on the first ring.

"I was just about to call you," she said.

"Your parents' attorney filed a motion twenty minutes ago.

He's trying to challenge your grandmother's codicil on the grounds of diminished capacity."

I stopped on the sidewalk.

"They're claiming she wasn't of sound mind when she wrote it."

"Yes," Eleanor said.

May you like

"And Claire — we need to talk about who their attorney is.

Because I think you know him."

Related Stories

Other posts