Chapter 6: The Night He Thought He Was Winning

Patricia was at her desk when I arrived, jacket still on, the text message already printed and paper-clipped to a new folder.
I laid Carla's documents beside it.
Patricia went through each page slowly, the way she always did, making small marks in the margins with a pencil.
When she finished, she set the pencil down and looked across the desk at me.
"This is enough to open a formal financial investigation," she said.
"The pattern Carla documented, combined with your father's accountant's records and the bank statements, establishes a clear picture."
"He threatened my clients," I said.
"Yes.
And that threat, sent in writing, constitutes attempted economic coercion and potentially tortious interference.
He has given us a weapon he didn't intend to hand over." She opened her desk drawer and removed a second business card, which she slid across to me.
"This is Daniel Marsh.
He is a forensic accountant I have worked with on three prior cases.
I want to bring him in tomorrow morning."
"What about Nathan's threat?
Can he actually damage my business?"
"He can attempt to.
But the moment he contacts your clients with false allegations, he exposes himself to defamation and additional civil liability.
And if we file before he makes contact — which we will, first thing tomorrow — any action he takes afterward will look exactly like what it is: retaliation." She paused.
"I want to ask you something.
The account that has your name on it — have you accessed it in the past eighteen months?"
"No.
Nathan handled all the transactions.
I signed the opening paperwork and that was the end of my involvement."
"Good.
The access logs will show that.
It will support your position that you were a nominal signatory, not a directing party."
My phone lit up on the edge of the desk.
Nathan again.
I showed Patricia.
*I'm serious, Emily.
You want to do this the hard way, then we'll do it the hard way.
My attorney is already involved.
He says the house is marital property.
Half of everything your studio earned during our marriage is mine.
You want to think about that before you do something you can't take back.*
Patricia read it.
"His attorney has apparently told him about community property," she said.
"What he has not told him, because he presumably does not yet know, is that a portion of what he is attempting to claim as marital assets was systematically redirected away from the marital estate by Nathan himself.
Which disqualifies him from claiming those funds in equitable distribution." She looked at me.
"He is negotiating from a position he does not understand is already compromised."
For the first time that day, I felt something loosen in my chest.
"He thinks he's ahead," I said.
"He thinks he moved first.
He didn't."
I drove back to my mother's house at ten o'clock.
The children were asleep.
My mother was at the kitchen table with a cup of tea going cold beside her, waiting the way she had been waiting for two days.
I sat down across from her.
"Patricia is filing tomorrow," I said.
My mother exhaled slowly.
"And Carla?" she asked.
"She gave me everything.
Fourteen months of documentation."
My mother was quiet for a moment.
"Your father knew," she said.
"He couldn't prove it.
He was sick and he was afraid of what it would do to you to find out while he was still here.
So he left the letter and he hoped it wouldn't be necessary." She looked at her hands.
"He told me once that the worst thing about watching someone you love be mistreated is knowing they have to be the one to see it for themselves.
You can't take the blindfold off for them."
I thought about Nathan at the coffee shop in the rain.
The blueprints.
The olive conversation.
The man I had chosen.
"I did love him," I said.
"I need you to know that.
It wasn't nothing."
"I know," my mother said.
"I just loved a version of him that he stopped being a very long time ago.
Maybe never was entirely."
She reached across and put her hand over mine.
Same gesture as the night before.
Same steadiness.
"What happens now?" she asked.
"Tomorrow, we find out how much he actually took."
Then her home phone rang.
An old landline she kept for emergencies, the number known to almost no one.
My mother's face changed when she looked at the screen.
"It's Judith," she said.
May you like
We looked at each other across the kitchen table.
Nathan's mother had never once called my mother in twelve years of marriage.