Spotlight

Chapter 8: What Patrick Knew

Patrick came in person.

That surprised Ruth, though she didn't say so out loud.

She simply rearranged the chairs in her conference room and told me to let her lead.

He arrived at nine the following morning with a younger attorney I didn't recognize and an expression that was trying very hard to be neutral.

He was heavier than I remembered from Nathan's birthday.

His hair had gone gray at the temples.

He set a leather briefcase on the table with the careful placement of a man who needed the room to understand that he was important.

Ruth let him arrange himself.

Then she sat down, opened her folder, and looked at him.

"Your client understands the nature of the filing?" she said.

"My client is here to discuss a resolution," his attorney said.

"In good faith.

He believes this situation arose from a miscommunication about the scope of his authority in the matter."

"The scope of his authority to file a forged signature at the county recorder's office," Ruth said.

A small pause.

"That characterization—" Patrick's attorney began.

"Is accurate," Ruth said.

"Would you like to see the comparison document?

We have Emily's verified signature from the original mortgage, from her bank records, and from the IRS filing from the same calendar year.

Set against the signature on the amendment, a handwriting specialist will spend approximately four minutes reaching a conclusion."

Patrick's hands moved slightly on the table.

"What does your client want?" his attorney asked.

Ruth looked at me.

"I'll speak for myself," I said.

Patrick looked at me for the first time.

He'd been avoiding it since he sat down.

"I want the amendment reversed and my name restored as sole owner of the property," I said.

"I want the loan application formally withdrawn and any lender communications on file transferred to my attorney.

I want a signed statement from you acknowledging that the amendment was filed without my knowledge or consent.

And I want it done within seventy-two hours."

"And in exchange?" his attorney asked.

"In exchange," Ruth said, "we hold at the civil level and do not escalate to the district attorney's office at this time."

Patrick's jaw moved.

He looked at his attorney.

Something passed between them.

"There is one complication," Patrick said.

He spoke directly to me, not to Ruth.

Like he was trying to find some version of this where it was still a conversation between two people who knew each other.

"The lender has already performed a preliminary assessment," he said.

"Reversing the application creates a record of a failed filing.

That will follow Nathan in any future—"

"Patrick," I said.

He stopped.

"Nathan let his sister hjt me in front of my children," I said.

"And then he tried to take my house.

I am not here to protect Nathan's credit history."

Silence.

His attorney spoke quietly into Patrick's ear.

Patrick stared at the table.

"We'll need until end of business Friday," his attorney said.

"You have until Thursday at noon," Ruth said.

Patrick looked up.

"That's not enough time to—"

"Thursday at noon," Ruth said again.

Pleasantly.

Completely without movement.

Another consultation.

Patrick nodded, very slightly.

As they stood to leave, Patrick paused at the door.

He turned back.

"I told Nathan this was a mistake," he said.

It was directed at me.

Something in it wanted me to believe him.

Wanted some version of absolution.

"Then you should have said no," I said.

He left without another word.

Ruth waited until the outer door closed.

"He'll comply," she said.

"He has too much to lose.

His license, for a start."

"Nathan put him up to it," I said.

"Yes." Ruth sat down across from me.

"But Patrick is the one who filed.

That distinction will matter for the rest of his career." She paused.

"Emily.

There's something else we need to discuss."

I looked at her.

"In going through your financial records from the last three years, my assistant found something." Ruth opened a second folder.

"A joint account you mentioned — the household expense account."

"Yes."

"In the eighteen months preceding the title amendment, there were sixteen transfers from that account.

Small amounts.

Between four hundred and nine hundred dollars.

Each labeled as household maintenance." She turned the folder toward me.

"None of them match any contractor, utility, or service provider."

I looked at the list.

"Where did the money go?" I asked.

"To an account registered to a company called Voss Property Holdings LLC," Ruth said.

Voss.

Patrick's name.

The transfers had started two months after Patrick walked through my house asking about the roof.

Ruth watched me read to the bottom of the list.

"He was paying Patrick," I said.

"Out of the household account.

For three years."

"That is what the records show," Ruth said.

I set the page down.

"How much total?"

Ruth turned to the last line.

Eleven thousand, two hundred and forty dollars.

From the account we'd opened for grocery runs and utility bills.

I had written him a check every month for the household account without ever once questioning where the money was going.

Twelve years.

He had never once been who I thought he was.

Ruth's phone rang on the table between us.

She glanced at the screen and then at me.

"It's Nathan's attorney," she said.

I nodded.

She answered it.

Listened.

Her expression didn't change.

She covered the receiver and looked at me.

May you like

"Nathan is filing for divorce," she said.

"He wants to move first."

Related Stories

Other posts