Chapter 1: The Most Expensive Salad I Ever Ordered

My SIL faked an emergency to stick me with their $487 dinner bill—so I invited her and my brother to a spa to celebrate her "recovery" with a little "surprise."
My brother, Dan, and his wife, Claire, took me to a fancy restaurant to celebrate my promotion.
I'd waited six years for it.
"Our treat, Jenna," Dan said.
"You've earned it."
Our parents had always called Dan "the charming one." I was "the dependable one," which in my family meant the one who paid for things quietly.
Claire hugged me at the door.
"We're so proud of you.
Order anything."
So I trusted them.
Dan ordered the lobster tails.
Claire ordered Wagyu steak, two glasses of prosecco.
I didn't want them to spend so much money on me.
Their attention was the thing that mattered.
So I just ordered a Caesar salad.
At 9:40, as Claire finished her chocolate lava cake and Dan was ordering a second crème brûlée, Claire suddenly stopped laughing.
"I need the restroom," she murmured.
When she came back, her face was gray.
Her lips were almost white.
She gripped the back of the chair.
"Dan," she whispered, "my chest...
I think something's wrong.
We need the hospital.
Now."
Dan jumped up so fast his chair fell over.
"Jenna, I'm so sorry, we have to go."
"Go!
Go, of course.
Call me the second you know anything."
"Could you...?" He gestured at the check, and for a second he couldn't meet my eyes.
"I'll pay you back."
"Don't even think about it."
They hurried out.
Claire leaned on him with one hand pressed to her chest.
The bill was $487.
I paid it with trembling hands and left a tip.
I walked home.
It was a mile and a half, and I needed the cold air.
I kept checking my phone.
Nothing.
Then I passed a bar called The Anchor.
Through the window, under a neon beer sign, I spotted my brother.
Dan was leaning back in a booth with a pint of beer.
Claire was beside him.
She was laughing.
She had color in her cheeks.
She wasn't holding her chest.
She was holding a cocktail.
I stood there for a full minute, waiting for my brain to explain it.
It didn't.
I slipped inside and stood behind a pillar, close enough to hear.
"Did you see her face?" Claire was saying.
"She looked like she was going to cry!
Oh, honestly, I should've been an actress."
Dan snorted.
"You're terrible."
"The white powder trick, babe!
Worked like a charm.
A little makeup, and suddenly I'm dying!"
She clinked her glass against his.
"When else would we get lobster and prosecco on someone else's tab?
You're welcome.
Happy anniversary."
Dan laughed so hard he had to wipe his eyes.
My stomach turned.
Then I walked out, and nobody saw me.
I couldn't believe they did it to me.
At first, I cried.
But then I decided it was enough.
So, two days later, I called them.
"Claire!
How are you feeling?
I've been so worried."
There was a short pause, then a weak, practiced voice.
"The doctors said it was a heart scare.
Combined with food poisoning.
I'm much better now."
"Oh, thank God," I said warmly.
"You know what you need?
Rest.
I'm booking you both a recovery day on Saturday.
My treat."
"Jenna, you don't have to..."
"I insist.
After everything you did for me.
I've even picked out a little surprise for you both."
After they changed into the spa's white robes, I met them in the lounge.
"So where's this surprise?" Dan laughed.
I set a small white box on the table between us.
Black ribbon.
When I slid it across, something inside rolled with a soft, dry rattle.
"A get-well gift," I said.
"For both of you."
Dan pulled the ribbon with two fingers, still smiling.
He lifted the lid.
The smile didn't fade.
It just stopped, like a video freezing on a bad frame.
Claire leaned over his shoulder.
Her glass slipped from her hand and shattered on the marble.
May you like
"What the hell?" she whispered.
"How dare you?!"