Chapter 10: Everything He Thought He Could Take

My father made his move on a Thursday, three weeks later.
He didn't call Ruth's office again.
He was smarter than that this time.
He went directly to the insurance company.
He had done his research — found the name of the policy provider, gotten himself in front of a claims representative, and filed a formal inquiry under the category of disputed beneficiary designation.
His argument, as Ruth explained it to me the next morning, was that Daniel had been mentally incapacitated at the time of the beneficiary change, that I had exploited a vulnerable dying man, and that as a family member with direct knowledge of the circumstances, he was requesting a formal review.
"He submitted a written statement," Ruth said.
"Saying what?"
"Largely what we expected.
That you isolated Daniel.
That you controlled his access to family and medical information.
That the beneficiary change was made without full understanding or consent.
He included a reference to the paternity documentation, arguing that its inclusion in the estate file was itself evidence of your planning and manipulation."
I listened to all of it.
"He used the paternity documentation," I said.
"Yes."
"Daniel put that documentation in the file specifically to protect Clara," I said.
"And he's using it to argue that I'm manipulative."
"Yes," Ruth said.
"I know."
"What does the insurance company do with this?"
"They'll review the inquiry.
They have forty-five days.
But Nora — this is thin.
The policy beneficiary change was made eighteen months before Daniel's death, witnessed and notarized, with no prior challenge.
The documentation in the estate file was prepared by an attorney of record.
Daniel's written statement addresses exactly this type of claim." Ruth paused.
"But I have to be honest with you.
This buys your father time.
It generates uncertainty.
And if he can find anyone else willing to submit a supporting statement, it gets more complicated."
"Thomas," I said immediately.
"Yes," Ruth said.
"Thomas is the name that comes to mind."
I called Thomas that afternoon.
He picked up on the second ring.
I told him what had happened.
There was a long silence on his end.
"He called me last week," Thomas said.
"My father.
Asked if I would be willing to speak to someone.
I told him I wasn't.
He said I was making a mistake."
"Thomas —"
"I told him no," he said.
"I want you to know that.
I told him no, and I told him that I had spoken with you, and I told him that Daniel had left a written statement that would bury any challenge he tried to make." A pause.
"He hung up."
"Does your mother know what he's doing?" I said.
"Probably," Thomas said.
"She won't stop him.
Not because she agrees with him, but because she doesn't stop things once they're in motion.
She never has."
I sat with that for a moment.
"I need to ask you something," I said.
"And I need you to be honest with me."
"Okay," he said.
"Is there anyone — anyone in your family, anyone connected to Daniel, anyone from his old professional circle — who might be willing to support your father's version?
Who might have actually believed what your mother was saying about me?"
Thomas was quiet.
"There's one person," he said slowly.
"Daniel's old business partner.
Greg.
They had a falling out about two years before Daniel got sick.
Money disagreement.
Greg thought Daniel cheated him on a contract split.
He didn't — I know the full story — but Greg believed it.
And he would not be sad to see Daniel's estate complicated."
"Does your father know Greg?"
"They've met," Thomas said.
"At one of Daniel's company events, years ago."
The feeling that went through me then was cold and specific.
"I need Greg's last name," I said.
"And whatever contact information you have for him."
"Why?"
"Because I need Ruth to know who might be coming," I said.
"And because Daniel prepared for this.
There's something in that file that I haven't read yet — Ruth mentioned a business file, separate from the personal statement.
I think it's time I asked to see it."
I called Ruth back within the hour.
"The business file," I said.
"Daniel put one together."
A brief pause.
"He did."
"What's in it?"
"Correspondence," Ruth said carefully.
"Between Daniel and Greg Halloran, dating back four years.
And an independent accounting report that Daniel commissioned eighteen months before his death.
It addresses the disputed contract split."
"The report that Greg claimed Daniel cheated him on."
"Yes," Ruth said.
"The report that confirms Daniel's version of events, in full, with documentation."
Something clicked into place.
"Greg went after Daniel's reputation," I said.
"And Daniel knew he might come after mine."
"Daniel was a thorough man," Ruth said.
"Send me the file," I said.
"All of it.
And I need you to contact the insurance company directly — not to argue, just to introduce yourself as estate counsel and let them know that a full evidentiary file exists and will be available upon formal request."
"That will signal to them that the challenge is contested and documented," Ruth said.
"Good," I said.
"I want them to know that before my father's forty-five days are up."
"I'll reach out today," Ruth said.
I ended the call and sat at the table.
Clara was in the bouncer, awake, watching the mobile above her turn slowly in the air from the heating vent.
She had Daniel's concentration when she was focused on something.
The way she went completely still and just watched.
"He prepared for all of it," I told her.
"He thought of everything."
She reached for the mobile and missed by several inches, which didn't seem to bother her at all.
I picked up my phone and found the message thread with Thomas.
*Send me Greg's information when you can*, I wrote.
*And Thomas — thank you.
For telling him no.*
His reply came in two minutes.
*Daniel would have done the same for me.*
I set the phone down and looked at my daughter.
May you like
She had, finally, gotten hold of one corner of the mobile.
She held it like she had no intention of letting go.